It's an unknowable on Butch, but let me ask this. Were Butch's recruiting powers so great that he could get a 5 star defensive lineman to turn down $5M from the Aggies to come to Miami? Maybe on offense if he ran a spread he could negate the receiver issue, but in an NIL world can Butch Davis at the peak of his powers make a dent in A&M's recruiting on defense? Or does Prime Butch come with $50M in petty cash to spread around to his recruits?
2022 is a different world to 1999.
Let me ask YOU this!
When we were under NCAA sanctions - where were you?
Five stars? No five stars were coming to UM in those days! Soldinger said they didn't even have enough players to scrimmage at one point - it was that bad.
Butch found nuggets. Pure gold. He only had a few recruits at a time he could recruit - so he had to get grown-assed men - who wanted a chance. To prove themselves. To win.
They coached them up - but they coached them to be self-starters. That's why Clappy could sit on his *** - and win the National Championship.
What did he ask Reed, going in at halfttime? "What do you think I should say?" Reed: "I wouldn't say much Coach - we're ahead!"
At the end of this season - we should be rid of half our team. Douche this team good.
You act like Butch later couldn't do much for other teams. Neither could Schnellenberger. Neither could Erickson. Neither could Clappy. Only JJ.
Teams, locations, and Coaches - only the perfect mix - combined together - reach synergistic levels unreachable anywhere else.
Mario wants to change EVERYTHING. Oline? Sure. Dline? Absolutely.
Offense? You have to be a dumbass to change from what works here.
Butch knew both sides of it.