Why recruit and sign Ryan Mayes and Mike Smith? Seems that they have very little chance to succeed.
This isn't defending them, nor Chumley or any of the coaches...but while we want every guy we recruit to be an All-American, you also need those guys who may not be every-down impact players, but can fill in the holes on Special Teams and on scout team in practices to give your offense/defense a good look at the opponent's gameplan as you've scouted it.
If Mayes/Smith don't end up being stars, maybe they're those types of guys instead. I'm alright with that. In a perfect world, sure, you want your backups and their backups to be as good as your starters...but this world ain't perfect.
Yeah but...
You try to sign as many studs as you can. Those studs play special teams until they're ready for full-time roles. You don't sign guys with the intent of them being full-time special teams players.
You sign the best players in your backyard and the worst case scenario is that they end up being a solid special teams contributor.
This is partially why our special teams suck, they're filled with JAGs. You want a special teams unit that is mostly filled with guys who will eventually be starters. That's how it's always been around here. Kellen Winslow and Andre Johnson played special teams before earning starting roles.
Remember when we would kick the ball off and our whole kick-off team would be down there before the returner even had a chance to get going? Yeah.
I agree w/that, and how it once was, as I alluded to by mentioning that you want your backups and their backups to be as good as your starters...but that's not always going to be the case.
To boot--Mayes/Smith came from Northwestern. It's not like this was a couple of kids from Delaware or Alaska that we took fliers on. These are those players in our backyard that we signed.
When the studs you want to sign are going to F$U, Bama, L$U, etc...you get the guys you can close on (which there have been far too many whiffs on), and then you try to coach them up (which we all know is a
major problem).
We're talking about 2 guys who are going to be RS Freshmen this season, too...acting like they're busts. They're not, at least, not yet. Their role as RS Freshmen IS that Special Teams/scout team guy role, unless they're a super-impact guy who's ready now. And if that were the case, they wouldn't have redshirted, would they?
Kellen Winslow/Andre Johnson aren't walking thru that door. We may have some guys with potential and talent, but we don't have that level of guy on the roster that we can make wait their turn and help us on Special Teams in the meantime. That's just not the makeup of this roster at this point in time. That's where we want to be, I agree, but to try to imply that Mayes/Smith are busts because they aren't those guys...that's just crazy talk. Different players, different eras, and definitely different (read: sh1ttier) coaching they're getting.