forums

Scrimmage take...

I'll post Rosiers full stats comparing him to ALL FBS QBs, and hopefully then to just P5 QBs pretty soon
Not Gunna keep on spamming that little chart only comparing him to the qualifying ACC qbs, because it doesn't completely show how *** he was.
PokemonFisherman said:
@calinative umstudent at this point we are beating a dead horse I feel like I'm arguing with a liberal when you present them facts they'll just screech .. So far the 9th time can you just post your case study for someone who obviously hasn't pained through all the games of last season and just goes "welp we are 10-3 we must be doing something right then"
Click to expand...
 
calinative umstudent said:
My views have nothing to do with any political identity though. They are purely mine. I don't agree with **** just because Conservatives/Liberals typically support something. I make my own decisions.
Click to expand...

Yea, I don’t care about the politics. I totally stay away from them here.

But I just thought his point was funny. He was denigrating the limited understanding capacity of a liberal to a liberal. I have nothing against liberals, or conservatives, or libertarians or anybody else. On this board, I’m neutral.
 
It really doesn't do it justice but yea I know you're posting it for the 12th time I just need it for my sanity
 
OriginalCanesCanesCanes said:
Yea, I don’t care about the politics. I totally stay away from them here.

But I just thought his point was funny. He was denigrating the limited understanding capacity of a liberal to a liberal. I have nothing against liberals, or conservatives, or libertarians or anybody else. On this board, I’m neutral.
Click to expand...
you agnostic ****. lol, jk
 
OkieCane said:
I also hear no talk of how his running ability helps the backs by holding DEs/LBers. That is probably his #1 asset.

I hope Jarren/Perry/anyone clearly TAKE the job, just don't see it
Click to expand...
I think ur overstating the case there. I never saw one single team leave a spy on him. They stack the box & run blitz most downs. No one ive seen accounts for his ability to run in any special circumstance. Thats not taking away from malik that its probably the strongest part to his game but it really just shows how lil opponents respect the pass with him (& for good reason)
 
Cribby said:
I don’t give a **** about his stats , dude won close games for them all season. And didn’t make bone headed decisions.

You’re comparing two different offenses and eras , KK didn’t have 8-10 layups a game back then. Keep *********ing to stats from different eras.

By your stupid logic Rosier is our best qb ever lol, I mean his stats are better.

Same logic all the greatest qbs in history are the last 5-6 years and played at Texas Tech , Wash St, Baylor and Okie State.
Click to expand...
Dont forget hawaii
 
Virginia placed a spy on him in the redzone. He threw a jump ball for a TD to Richards on one occasion. A second time the spy got blocked on Malik's run TD to seal the game. Wisconsin ran blitzes to stop the QB draw.
 
fincane said:
Virginia placed a spy on him in the redzone. He threw a jump ball for a TD to Richards on one occasion. A second time the spy got blocked on Malik's run TD to seal the game. Wisconsin ran blitzes to stop the QB draw.
Click to expand...
BINGO, at least one person in here actually watched. He also picked up a ton of 3rd and mediums with his legs. He is not very accurate, but the hate here is baffling to me.
 
LmAo

averaged 177 pass per game
6 pass TD 7 INT 1 rush TD
And a **** completion percentage final four games.

Rosier sucks bros

I mean, are we even really arguing?
He isn’t good at all

We ride NC States QB to playoffs last season.

And how dare anyone compare Rosier to Dorsey? Inconceivable
 
OkieCane said:
BINGO, at least one person in here actually watched. He also picked up a ton of 3rd and mediums with his legs. He is not very accurate, but the hate here is baffling to me.
Click to expand...
The problem with this is hes not any better of a runner than we could assume Perry, Jarren, or Weldon are. So yet again, I ask what the **** is the upside?
 
Brooklyndee said:
I think ur overstating the case there. I never saw one single team leave a spy on him. They stack the box & run blitz most downs. No one ive seen accounts for his ability to run in any special circumstance. Thats not taking away from malik that its probably the strongest part to his game but it really just shows how lil opponents respect the pass with him (& for good reason)
Click to expand...
Think I recall Tremaine Edmunds running a little QB spy. And I wouldn't be surprised if ND did too. But ultimately its not because he's some great runner, or even good runner. He's a solid runner. We just have so many offensive weapons that it it stretches the defense out giving him easy yards. And I think thats why VTech and ND then UVA put spys on him. Because they understood he's not really much of a threat in the passing game, might as well cut off his running ability.
 
calinative umstudent said:
The problem with this is hes not any better of a runner than we could assume Perry, Jarren, or Weldon are. So yet again, I ask what the **** is the upside?
Click to expand...
They have never taken a college snap, no way to know. AGAIN, he is average at best, but average qbs have won NCs.
My guess is he is under center vs. LSU. Richt won't sacrifice wins to start an inexperienced QB with potentially more upside. At least that is my thoughts. We have some monster classes lined up as of now.
 
Last edited:
OkieCane said:
They have never taken a college snap, no way to know. AGAIN, he is average at best, but average qbs have won NCs.
My guess is he is under center vs. LSU. Richt won't sacrifice wins to start an inexperienced QB with potentially more upside. At least that is my thoughts. We have some monster classes lined up as of now.
Click to expand...

You might be right.

The other three have an opportunity to take the job.

It’s there for the taking. They’ve got their health, three strong arms, six strong legs, and three good brains.

Do they have the work ethic and the will?

That’s the question, when you get right down to it.

You want something badly enough, you work your *** off for it.

Let’s see if one of them does.
 
Texxcane said:
Well said hater, I feel exactly the same about QB's. Give me a 6'4 honky that's so Damm slow he won't even consider running, that boy will stand tall in the pocket and deliver the pill to someone who can make a play. If worse comes to worse he flicks it out of play, from what I have read Williams may be that kid. Somebody needs to step up. We need to start getting our QB's from Texas, badass coaching from day one.
Click to expand...
Thanks. I like them under center also. All five NCs came that way. It is as Miami as JJs 4-3. But I still attend Mass and pray in Latin, so I trend against change. Just that Jim and Vinny were our best QBs and both were very mobile for their day. No NCs. In fairness, Kelly’s teams were not quite equal to the later ones but if our mates here are to be believed, if the QB is good that doesn’t matter.
 
Back
Top