forums

Scrimmage take...

OkieCane said:
Unfortunately the amount of tears here come Labor Day may drown us when 12 is under center
Click to expand...
That doesn't mean he's the better qb...i think that even if Perry performs better in the spring game, CMR goes with the vet. Not very smart but an old school coach will sometimes coach scary and safe instead of coaching to win and build upon.
 
404CANES said:
That doesn't mean he's the better qb...i think that even if Perry performs better in the spring game, CMR goes with the vet. Not very smart but an old school coach will sometimes coach scary and safe instead of coaching to win and build upon.
Click to expand...

I agree, but I promise you Richt will start the QB HE THINKS gives us the best chance to WIN. That's the ultimate goal, we have stacked classes lined up for the next two recruiting cycles. WINNING matters, not who message board heroes think is the "best" QB that hasn't played a down in college. Richt knows this.

That said I hope one of the young guys take the job, I'm all for it, so is he I'm sure.
 
OkieCane said:
YOU said he was the worst in the ACC, YOU were mistaken. Crowns got nothing to do with your errors.
Click to expand...

He can start at schools who didn't even offer him a scholarship but I was mistaken...

He wouldn't start in Temple. We should crown you.
 
OkieCane said:
Do you actually watch games????

We beat Duke (Overall #21 D in the nation) 31-6, he had 270 yards passing, 2TD (A 163 QB rating) and ran for 45 yards and a TD.

Against UNC he threw for 356 yards and 3TDs, on the road in a win

Against UVA he threw for 3 TDs and ran for another TD in a blowout win

Tell me you are not serious?? TELL ME

SMH, you are no longer to give QB "analysis" IMO
Click to expand...

Apparently you don't watch the games either. He was horribly inaccurate for the games I listed. Cool, spout off the yards that he got per game. Let me know how many 3 and outs he had on the year because he couldn't make a simple 5 yard pass.

You come off as an overused prison fck boy with how you stick up for Rosier. Fck out of here telling someone to stay out of any QB analysis when you're sticking up for one that likely wouldn't start for any other ACC school.
 
OkieCane said:
You tried to say he played like crap in 3 games he went 3-0 and accounted for 10 TDs, no need to rebut that idiocy my man
Click to expand...

PokemonFisherman said:
Bro are you actually defending the unc game ? 3/10 troll

And you're fooling yourself if you're calling uva a blowout

We didn't even bust the duke game wide open until half time ...

Did you watch any games jabroni
Click to expand...

Its replies like this that kill your credibility. UNC ran for almost 200 yards we ran for 60, but that game is somehow Rosiers fault, his completion percentage was crap for sure, but he did more to win that game than anyone not named Jaquan Johnson, Rosier had a keeper on 3rd and 7 to seal the game, if anything we won because of him. Not in spite.
 
I think a majority of the people here are of the opinion that we've seen the best Malik Roseir has to offer. 5th year seniors who have had accuracy issues for their entire career don't become accurate all of the sudden. That's not to say he's garbage, he threw a lot of touchdown passes and bailed the offense out with some timely runs but he's also limited physically. The accuracy has been talked about ad nauseam and he led the ACC in interceptions thrown.

If you watched this offense last year, you'd see that they did not ask Malik to do very much outside of the most basic QB responsibilities. No checks or changes. Super basic pre snap reads. One read and run post snap stuff. The offense was watered down almost to high school levels. Jarren Williams was probably doing all that and more in high school last year. The stuff they're running isn't something that requires years of learning to master. My point is, if you're going to water down the offense for a 5th year, low ceiling guy, why not just water it down for a younger guy with a much higher ceiling? I mean by all means, if the young guys are still lost by the time Labor Day rolls around, then go with the senior. But it speaks to the coaching if the younger guys can't get a handle on this super basic offense. Especially when you see redshirt freshmen and even true freshmen lighting it up at other schools.
 
3 Wins - 0 Losses

QB Ratings of:
162
142
138

These are "crap" games


Oh the wisdom here..........
 
QuatroCane said:
Its replies like this that kill your credibility. UNC ran for almost 200 yards we ran for 60, but that game is somehow Rosiers fault, his completion percentage was crap for sure, but he did more to win that game than anyone not named Jaquan Johnson, Rosier had a keeper on 3rd and 7 to seal the game, if anything we won because of him. Not in spite.
Click to expand...

In the latter portion of the year, defenses knew that they could play the run and try and force Rosier to beat them with their arm. Apparently you don't watch games either.
 
orange&green84 said:
Apparently you don't watch the games either. He was horribly inaccurate for the games I listed. Cool, spout off the yards that he got per game. Let me know how many 3 and outs he had on the year because he couldn't make a simple 5 yard pass.

You come off as an overused prison fck boy with how you stick up for Rosier. Fck out of here telling someone to stay out of any QB analysis when you're sticking up for one that likely wouldn't start for any other ACC school.
Click to expand...


Take the L man, it was a Hard L too...... you spoke out your *** and were wrong, it happens
 
OkieCane said:
Take the L man, it was a Hard L too...... you spoke out your *** and were wrong, it happens
Click to expand...
Where was I wrong - that Malik's a horribly inaccurate passer? He was 54% on the year. He got benched during the Pitt game for Sherieffs because Rosier played like dog ****. Richt has even said he needs to vastly improve his accuracy. You're ******* dumb.
 
QuatroCane said:
Its replies like this that kill your credibility. UNC ran for almost 200 yards we ran for 60, but that game is somehow Rosiers fault, his completion percentage was crap for sure, but he did more to win that game than anyone not named Jaquan Johnson, Rosier had a keeper on 3rd and 7 to seal the game, if anything we won because of him. Not in spite.
Click to expand...
whatever helps you sleep man
 
orange&green84 said:
Apparently you don't watch the games either. He was horribly inaccurate for the games I listed. Cool, spout off the yards that he got per game. Let me know how many 3 and outs he had on the year because he couldn't make a simple 5 yard pass.

You come off as an overused prison fck boy with how you stick up for Rosier. Fck out of here telling someone to stay out of any QB analysis when you're sticking up for one that likely wouldn't start for any other ACC school.
Click to expand...

You don't deal well with differences of opinion do
orange&green84 said:
In the latter portion of the year, defenses knew that they could play the run and try and force Rosier to beat them with their arm. Apparently you don't watch games either.
Click to expand...

That makes no sense, are you putting the UNC game in that box?
 
OkieCane said:
So yards, wins and TDs DON'T matter, but completion % does?


LMAO, stop it
Click to expand...

Wins is a team stat. If we didn't have a really good defense, we could chalk up a few more Ls. Love guys that judge a QB based on wins. I guess Jalen Hurts is the best QB in the nation. Dude only lost two games his first two years. Amazing.
 
OkieCane said:
So yards, wins and TDs DON'T matter, but completion % does?


LMAO, stop it
Click to expand...
Bro you're pulling out stats to ... But if he pulls out stats to prove you wrong it's stupid ? It's a **** chat board bro if you can't handle the Internet then get off lol
 
Back
Top