• Attention: Register today to view CanesInSight Ad-Free for 7 days.

Rank Our Commits

nvlahos

Junior
Joined
Feb 14, 2012
Messages
3,567
Saw that 247 did an article on this. Thought it was interesting. Here's how I would rank them...


1. Josh Jobe
2. Lorenzo Lingard
3. Will Mallory
4. Mark Pope
5. Gurvan Hall
6. Nesta Silvera
7. Camron Davis
8. DJ Ivey
9. Brevin Jordan
10. Al Blades
11. Delone Scaife
12. Daquris Wiggins
13. Gilbert Frierson
14. Cleveland Reed
15. Brian Hightower
16. Gregory Rousseau
17. John Campbell
18. Artur Sitkowski
19. Bubba Baxa


IMO - Jobe, Lingard, Mallory, and Pope should all be 5 Stars

Criminally underrated - DJ Ivey, Dee Wiggins, Nesta, DJ Scaife - all should be mid-high 4 stars

Also not trying to discredit any of our recruits, as this is an unreal class and I look at all of them as solid 4 stars or higher.
 
Last edited:

canesupremacy

Sophomore
Joined
Feb 19, 2013
Messages
1,360
They are all important. These lists do not help our team recruit. No one wants to be ranked at the bottom. They will look for another team who appreciates their talent
 

Liberty City El

Dejazmach
Joined
May 14, 2016
Messages
18,832
1. Lorenzo Lingard
2. Mark Pope
3. Delone Scaife
4. Al Blades Jr
5. Gurvan Hall
6. Brevin Jordan
7. Camron Davis
8. Brian Hightower
9. DJ Ivey
10. Will Mallory
11. Josh Jobe
12. Cleveland Reed
13. Nesta Silvera
14. Gilbert Frierson
15. John Campbell
16. Daquris Wiggins
17. Gregory Rousseau
18. Artur Sitkowski
19. Bubba Baxa
 

kryptonite

AARP
Joined
Dec 13, 2012
Messages
11,261
1. Lorenzo Lingard
2. Mark Pope
3. Delone Scaife
4. Al Blades Jr
5. Gurvan Hall
6. Brevin Jordan
7. Camron Davis
8. Brian Hightower
9. DJ Ivey
10. Will Mallory
11. Josh Jobe
12. Cleveland Reed
13. Nesta Silvera
14. Gilbert Frierson
15. John Campbell
16. Daquris Wiggins
17. Gregory Rousseau
18. Artur Sitkowski
19. Bubba Baxa

Man...people sleep on Bubba Baxa.
 
Joined
Jun 19, 2013
Messages
8,079
1. Lingard - Gives our class credibility
2. Silvera - NOTHING -- and I mean NOTHING -- like an elite DT.
3. Scaife - Trench bully.
4. Jobe
5. Pope
6. Blades
7. Hall
8. Cam
9. Hightower - I know it's hard to think of a 4 star at IMG as a steal, but I think this guy might end up being just that for us.
10. Jordan
11. Ivey
12. Mallory
13. Reed
14. Campbell
15. Wiggins
16. Frierson
17. Rousseau
18. Baxa
19. Sits

Would honestly be pissed if we lost any of numbers 1 - 16. All are major pieces.
 

Marcus4989

Redshirt Freshman
Joined
Jan 6, 2013
Messages
433
1. Lorenzo Lingard
2. Mark Pope
3. Josh Jobe
4. Nesta Silvera
5. Al Blades
6. Delone Scaife
7. Will Mallory
8. Gurvan Hall
9. Brevin Jordan
10. Gilbert Frierson
11. Brian Hightower
12. DJ Ivey
13. Camron Davis
14. Cleveland Reed
15. Daquris Wiggins
16. Artur Sitkowski
17. Gregory Rousseau
18. John Campbell
19. Bubba Baxa
 

Marcus4989

Redshirt Freshman
Joined
Jan 6, 2013
Messages
433
1. Lorenzo Lingard
2. Mark Pope
3. Delone Scaife
4. Al Blades Jr
5. Gurvan Hall
6. Brevin Jordan
7. Camron Davis
8. Brian Hightower
9. DJ Ivey
10. Will Mallory
11. Josh Jobe
12. Cleveland Reed
13. Nesta Silvera
14. Gilbert Frierson
15. John Campbell
16. Daquris Wiggins
17. Gregory Rousseau
18. Artur Sitkowski
19. Bubba Baxa

Curious that you have Jobe so low... I see Lingard, Pope, and Jobe as top 3 in this class regardless of who else we add (realistically... not counting pipe dreams)
 

Liberty City El

Dejazmach
Joined
May 14, 2016
Messages
18,832
1. Lorenzo Lingard
2. Mark Pope
3. Delone Scaife
4. Al Blades Jr
5. Gurvan Hall
6. Brevin Jordan
7. Camron Davis
8. Brian Hightower
9. DJ Ivey
10. Will Mallory
11. Josh Jobe
12. Cleveland Reed
13. Nesta Silvera
14. Gilbert Frierson
15. John Campbell
16. Daquris Wiggins
17. Gregory Rousseau
18. Artur Sitkowski
19. Bubba Baxa

Curious that you have Jobe so low... I see Lingard, Pope, and Jobe as top 3 in this class regardless of who else we add (realistically... not counting pipe dreams)
Just my opinion that's all.
 

FrancisSawyer

Senior
Joined
Jan 15, 2012
Messages
4,989
1. Lorenzo Lingard
2. Mark Pope
3. Delone Scaife
4. Al Blades Jr
5. Gurvan Hall
6. Brevin Jordan
7. Camron Davis
8. Brian Hightower
9. DJ Ivey
10. Will Mallory
11. Josh Jobe
12. Cleveland Reed
13. Nesta Silvera
14. Gilbert Frierson
15. John Campbell
16. Daquris Wiggins
17. Gregory Rousseau
18. Artur Sitkowski
19. Bubba Baxa

In trying to make my own list I'm just blown away by how elite this entire class is. Let me give it a shot..........

1. Lorenzo Lingard
2. Will Mallory (No I'm not joking)
3. Nesta Silvera(He will be a factor from the get)
4. Delone Scaife
5. Gurvan Hall
6. Mark Pope
7. DJ Ivey
8. Josh Jobe
9. Gilbert Frierson
10. Al Blades
11. Daquris Wiggins
12. Camron Davis
13. Brian Hightower
14. Brevin Jordan
15. Cleveland Reed
16. Gregory Rousseau
17. John Campbell
18. Artur Sitkowski
19. Bubba Baxa

This class has amazing depth which made this a tough exercise. Can't wait to get these kids enrolled.
 

marshallrc13

Senior
Joined
Nov 5, 2011
Messages
2,511
6. Nesta Silvera
11. Delone Scaife
14. Cleveland Reed
2. Lorenzo Lingard
17. John Campbell
1. Josh Jobe
8. DJ Ivey
3. Will Mallory
4. Mark Pope
10. Al Blades
13. Gilbert Frierson
15. Brian Hightower
5. Gurvan Hall
7. Camron Davis
9. Brevin Jordan
12. Daquris Wiggins
16. Gregory Rousseau
18. Artur Sitkowski
19. Bubba Baxa

Here's my ranking. I left OP numbers for comparison. I put more stock in the OL/DL and having a stud RB than I do the other positions but to each his own.
 
Top