- Joined
- Nov 12, 2015
- Messages
- 15,409
Suppose Miami hired a guy without playcalling experience. Is your fear that he is going to call for a punt on 2nd down? I don't understand this obsession with playcalling experience.
We just had one of the most experienced and "successful" OCs in football (2 national championships, Heisman candidates) and he was awful since he ran an archaic system. I wouldn't take a chance on a fake OC in title only like Thomas Brown, but a guy like Bedenbaugh who actually designed the offense (I think the Clemson guy did too) is worth the risk, especially as he is very well known and would get recruits fired up.
I was half-kidding. No, I don’t think a new playcaller would punt on 2nd down. I do think playcalling is important. More interested if the candidate was fully involved in game planning. Like Bedenbaugh, Jeff Scott, and others.