I usually see eye to eye with you, but out of high school he had the lowest ceiling, with McCloud having the highest. Then in college, it was always Shaq the highest and then a distinct Pinckney. And I love Pinckney.
This is what I meant by my statement: Shaq clearly was the crown jewel of the class, #5 LB in the nation, top 247 ranked player. McCloud, another 4 star LB, w/ Pinck being a 3 star.
Stars be damned, Pinck was an intriguing prospect & had a lot of excited due to his natural abilities.
-W/ Shaq, we saw a well coached kid, but showed some athletic limitations, but look like a high IQ, sure tackler type of LB… Old School, if u will.
-W/ McCloud, he always looked like a guy who was a no man’s land type of player, not quite a DE & not quite a LB.
-W/ Pinckney, dude showed crazy blitz instincts & a TFL machine. He flashed & showed those same abilities, and that FSU come back was a thing of beauty for him.
I’m not so sure about McCloud, but I believe w/ better coaching, both Shaq & Pinck would’ve had way better careers here.