Tbh we should of gone for it. Now I'm not saying it is a bad decision to kick it, but going for it would have been better.
It was 4th and 1 and we were like at the 40-45 yard line. First if we don't get a yard on FSU we don't deserve to win, period. Second even if they get the ball at the 45, they need a touchdown to win, so being close to field goal range does not matter. It actually may help because if they score it should give us time for an attempt to score as well and once you get closer to the endzone it is harder to draw up plays for the TD, especially in the passing game.
Now once they made the decision to punt there is no way you can just look at the returner and stay in front of him. Two guys should always been trained to get behind him for if he doesn't catch it or he muffs it. This is common sense.