How is kneeling during the pledge telling veterans to go **** themselves? It was a vet that recomended that Kap start kneeling. Not only that, but those vets fought for their right to peacefully protest. If you want to live in a country like North Korea that forces people to pledge then that is your right and you can form your own protest. It brought massive awareness to police brutality. Everybody who hasn't been living under a rock now knows about the issue(some people don't care and would rather try and build up a straw man in order to deflect the message). No one kneeling is thinking "**** the vets". They could do other protests and people would find a way to try and claim the message is disrespectful to a certain group.
agree. but if any of them become snowflakes and take a knee and disrespect the country and our military, I will turn off the channel and tell them to punt sand
White immigrants weren’t always considered white — and acceptable
U can’t bring up your struggles (especially not when the topic is black oppression) as a badge of honor when your path out from under it was stepping onto the necks of black people yourselves. Y’all fought to become those who oppressed you as well, as “white people”. This historical fact renders the Irish “me too” point null and void.
All our dead servicemen that died in action bled and died for the ANTHEM? So you think they died for a song?
I thought they died for the United States and to defend freedom. Silly me! It turns out they died defending a song!
U can’t realistically intend to unite people on your terms only. As a black man and with our experiences and history in America I cannot afford to ignore the roots of things, the creator’s history or the country’s history, that’s a luxury or privilege that we’ve never had. U can’t have a history such as ours and then voluntarily turn a blind eye to what’s occurring right now and not see the correlation and precedent. The paternalism is a passive form of it and it needs to cease. The anthem doesn’t give me those warm fuzzy feelings inside, never has and that’s coming from a person whose ancestors are indigenous to Turtle Island and were on this land before any of its immigrants.of course they didnt die for a song. just like the players arent protesting a song.
the anthem is more than just a collection of patterned soundwaves. the moment, the melody, the the ceremony, the pageantry... the sum of the entire experience represents something more than any individual piece. the anthem is more than it's creator's history, or its country's history, for that matter. like all things known in our universe, it evolves & changes with the people that recognize it. words, thoughts, phrases, tools, and yes, songs, are re-purposed and reused all the time.
it is a unifying call, that says regardless of our differences(on the field and off), at the end of this game, we still realize that we are something greater than a football game. this is why we now perform the anthem before the game begins. think of it similar to the ceremony of prayer before a meal, that represents being grateful for being able to sit with family/loved ones and enjoy life giving nourishment together. its about being able to realize in that present moment that we are all one(in a certain, specific sense of the word). propaganda? sure, if that's your world view, we can call it that. but its all a part of the process of nation building, and nation sustaining.. a tool to expand and enforce our "in-group", cohesion.
the reason its been targeted as a means for protest is because of its effectiveness. not as a protest against a song, but as a protest against the unifying call of a people. protesters are claiming, we dont accept your call for unification. we dont recognize it in the way that you do. what you call unity is a farce to us. i think seen through this lens, its understandable why it upsets so many people. it should also be understandable why its seen as a just protest.
my gut reaction to the protesting is that i dont like it. but, im guessing thats the point.
I'm a vet. Served in the USMC. It always amazed me to see and hear people who NEVER served or even ran from it brag about their patriotism or worse yet have the audacity to try and speak for vets.
In short, taking the knee doesn't bother me or other vets I know at all........not to say that it may not bother some.
I was not speaking for all vets and I have the physical limitations and pain from two wars and two expeditionary conflicts as a memento for my service.
You realize there is context, right?
View attachment 61087
I grew up with this image and have never found it offensive. John Carlos and Tommie Smith had a defined purpose, messaging ,and even the Australian in front, the Silver Medalist, is also wearing a Human Rights patch that Carlos and Smith wore (he did it to protest Australia's harsh anti-Aboriginal policies). These men were amateurs and in the end paid a terrible price. They even defied a request by Harry Edwards to boycott the Olympics, instead making a statement much more powerful by an order of magnitude over a simple boycott. Here is what Smith has said about what happened:
“I don’t like the idea of people looking at it as negative,” Smith said. “There was nothing but a raised fist in the air and a bowed head, acknowledging the American flag — not symbolizing a hatred for it.”
As you said, some vets might be bothered. Shouldn't the kneeling have stopped when even some of the vets took offense and believe it symbolizes disrespect to the USA?
Carlos and Smith sent a powerful message of self-empowerment, pride, and a forthright resolution to change things for the better.
The NFL kneeling unecessarily divides us.
The NFL kneeling unecessarily divides us.
I was not speaking for all vets and I have the physical limitations and pain from two wars and two expeditionary conflicts as a memento for my service.
You realize there is context, right?
View attachment 61087
I grew up with this image and have never found it offensive. John Carlos and Tommie Smith had a defined purpose, messaging ,and even the Australian in front, the Silver Medalist, is also wearing a Human Rights patch that Carlos and Smith wore (he did it to protest Australia's harsh anti-Aboriginal policies). These men were amateurs and in the end paid a terrible price. They even defied a request by Harry Edwards to boycott the Olympics, instead making a statement much more powerful by an order of magnitude over a simple boycott. Here is what Smith has said about what happened:
“I don’t like the idea of people looking at it as negative,” Smith said. “There was nothing but a raised fist in the air and a bowed head, acknowledging the American flag — not symbolizing a hatred for it.”
As you said, some vets might be bothered. Shouldn't the kneeling have stopped when even some of the vets took offense and believe it symbolizes disrespect to the USA?
Carlos and Smith sent a powerful message of self-empowerment, pride, and a forthright resolution to change things for the better.
The NFL kneeling unecessarily divides us.
You think everyone was A-OK with the fist in the air? LMAOOOO
Divide and Conquer tactic (one black expression of protest was cool, but this new one is not). The same people saying this, hated the Olympic protest when it occurred saying it was the wrong way to protest. If I ignored history like I was advised to do earlier, I wouldn’t have been able to snuff out this divide and conquer post. See how that works..I was not speaking for all vets and I have the physical limitations and pain from two wars and two expeditionary conflicts as a memento for my service.
You realize there is context, right?
View attachment 61087
I grew up with this image and have never found it offensive. John Carlos and Tommie Smith had a defined purpose, messaging ,and even the Australian in front, the Silver Medalist, is also wearing a Human Rights patch that Carlos and Smith wore (he did it to protest Australia's harsh anti-Aboriginal policies). These men were amateurs and in the end paid a terrible price. They even defied a request by Harry Edwards to boycott the Olympics, instead making a statement much more powerful by an order of magnitude over a simple boycott. Here is what Smith has said about what happened:
“I don’t like the idea of people looking at it as negative,” Smith said. “There was nothing but a raised fist in the air and a bowed head, acknowledging the American flag — not symbolizing a hatred for it.”
As you said, some vets might be bothered. Shouldn't the kneeling have stopped when even some of the vets took offense and believe it symbolizes disrespect to the USA?
Carlos and Smith sent a powerful message of self-empowerment, pride, and a forthright resolution to change things for the better.
The NFL kneeling unecessarily divides us.
I was not speaking for all vets and I have the physical limitations and pain from two wars and two expeditionary conflicts as a memento for my service.
You realize there is context, right?
View attachment 61087
I grew up with this image and have never found it offensive. John Carlos and Tommie Smith had a defined purpose, messaging ,and even the Australian in front, the Silver Medalist, is also wearing a Human Rights patch that Carlos and Smith wore (he did it to protest Australia's harsh anti-Aboriginal policies). These men were amateurs and in the end paid a terrible price. They even defied a request by Harry Edwards to boycott the Olympics, instead making a statement much more powerful by an order of magnitude over a simple boycott. Here is what Smith has said about what happened:
“I don’t like the idea of people looking at it as negative,” Smith said. “There was nothing but a raised fist in the air and a bowed head, acknowledging the American flag — not symbolizing a hatred for it.”
As you said, some vets might be bothered. Shouldn't the kneeling have stopped when even some of the vets took offense and believe it symbolizes disrespect to the USA?
Carlos and Smith sent a powerful message of self-empowerment, pride, and a forthright resolution to change things for the better.
The NFL kneeling unecessarily divides us.
You do realize that ANY protest of ANYTHING that isn't status quo is going to ruffle somebody's feathers? It can't be helped
You're entitled to your feelings. Mine differ
They are entitled to protest in a way that THEY see fit ...not just one that meets your approval ....as long as they aren't hurting anyone.
That may not please EVERYONE but in America we don't get to choose how someone else chooses to protest or vote.
I accept the fact that everyone else is not going to do or act the way I'd like them to... because they have free choice....and I also accept that I cannot impose my will and desires on others regardless of how "right" I feel I may be.
Its no use discussing this further, we obviously feel very differently on the subject.
I'd much rather focus on WHY they are protesting than PC policing them on how they are doing it.....and focusing on the "WHY" shouldn't divide Americans at all because we all want the same.
Have a good one
How is kneeling during the pledge telling veterans to go **** themselves? It was a vet that recomended that Kap start kneeling. Not only that, but those vets fought for their right to peacefully protest. If you want to live in a country like North Korea that forces people to pledge then that is your right and you can form your own protest. It brought massive awareness to police brutality. Everybody who hasn't been living under a rock now knows about the issue(some people don't care and would rather try and build up a straw man in order to deflect the message). No one kneeling is thinking "**** the vets". They could do other protests and people would find a way to try and claim the message is disrespectful to a certain group.
Oh the country that just 50 plus years ago allowed a man of color the same rights as white man....right? F the anthem if thats what it represents....gtfoh with that bled and died for crap....and thats to any military or veterans past or present....you're not going to war for my sake but for your country that allows such brutalities to go on....so what that make you....and to think....i thought we had the right to express ourselves. Its a game...it will go on whether you watch it or not
Most of us are not from Africa. Most of us “black people”, don’t know it but we are the indigenous peoples of Turtle Island or what’s now known as America. The Asian looking “Indian” that is popularly portrayed as the indigenous are truly later welcomed immigrants from Asia via the Bering Strait. Whether indigenous or forced here via TransAtlantic slavery, ALL of our ancestors have been on this land longer than yours, so who are you to tell anyone to leave?maybe go back to africa where they're kicking white people out in south africa for being.. white?
sounds like it's up your alley