Malik vs Kayaa

[snipergang]

Who do you think is better and what would our records be right now if kaaya was qb ?

 

[JgDaCane]

Kaaya we lose Fsu, Gt, Cuse, Unc, & possibly Toledo. So i’ll go with Rosier.

 

[Insanecane]

Kaka was kaka. Rosier makes poor decisions about half the time but when he does make a good read the pass is usually money.

 

[LoyalCane24]

With kaaya I think that the games would be more of a blowout against inferior teams. with rosier we are going to be close with every team.

But with kaaya we lose close games and rosier will win them.

Also kaaya is a ******* statue and it made me want to hang myself

 

[ChosenOne]

With kaaya I think that the games would be more of a blowout against inferior teams. with rosier we are going to be close with every team.

But with kaaya we lose close games and rosier will win them.

Also kaaya is a ****ing statue and it made me want to hang myself

This. Rosier kills drives with his sporadic accuracy.

 

[ddann]

It is an undeniable fact that Rosier has made plays with his feet that have changed the outcome of some of these games.

Kaaya couldn't do that.

 

[407cane]

i think people make kaaya out to be worse than he actually was... i say we would be 6-1 right now with kaaya

rosier has been better

 

[zoisgod]

Rosier shouldn't even be up for debate
he has won more games in 3/4 of a season than Kaaya did in 3 years

 

[Firesite]

No way in **** we win the FSU game. I think we would be better against the GTs and Syracuses though. Malik is the better fit with Richt. Hopefully Perry blows both of them out of the water when his time comes.

 

[Doppelganger]

i think people make kaaya out to be worse than he actually was...

Of course they do.

Because he's no longer on the team.

They'll do the same thing when Rosier's gone.

 

[Andrew]

Kaaya is more talented, but Rosier is a winner....

I will take the winner, Rosier.

 

[snipergang]

i think people make kaaya out to be worse than he actually was...

Of course they do.

Because he's no longer on the team.

They'll do the same thing when Rosier's gone.

Rosier already has the better career in my opinion.

 

[snipergang]

Kaaya is more talented, but Rosier is a winner....

I will take the winner, Rosier.

Rosier a winner, leader, and better athlete

 

[twalcott5]

Who do you think is better and what would our records be right now if kaaya was qb ?

No comparison. Malik is a complete QB. Kaaya's achille's heel at UM was his lack of mobility.

 

[DeadPoets]

Kaaya is more talented, but Rosier is a winner....

I will take the winner, Rosier.

This

 

[Doppelganger]

Kaaya is more talented, but Rosier is a winner....

I will take the winner, Rosier.

That winner stuff is kinda garbage.

Malik is also on a better team than Kaaya ever played on.

 

[nystateofmind]

Before today I would've said Rosier but I don't think Kaaya ever looked as bad as Rosier did today.

So I don't know. Let's see how the rest of the season plays out.

 

[Dwinstitles]

With kaaya I think that the games would be more of a blowout against inferior teams. with rosier we are going to be close with every team.

But with kaaya we lose close games and rosier will win them.

Also kaaya is a ****ing statue and it made me want to hang myself

right here

 

[SFbayCane]

The thing that never ceased to amaze me about Kayak was his ability to throw the fade route juuuuust far enough out of bounds so that no one could make a play, thus forcing us to punt on yet another wasted possession.

 

[404CANES]

The same ppl saying they like Rosier over Kaaya was jumping down his throat for declaring for the nfl...now he's a bum and how in the **** did he ever qb at the U. This fanbase...