It's hard to compare exact situations. The difference between winning and losing in the NFL is a real fine line. Teams go from last to first in 1 yr. Texans went from 1st pick to 9 wins with very few different pieces added. Chud took a rookie QB and the worst ranked offense the previous yr and raised them to 4th in total offense. He did have Steve Smith and two Cane Te's. So he did have a few more weapons than Bortles. I don't think my point was rediculous. Chud did well at every OC spot he held. Cleveland Carolina and of course Canes. But I guess your point was wherever he went they were already good. You can only judge by performance. Chud performed and IMO Jedd did not. Quit making excuse like many did with Golden. Judge by performance. JMO no need to get jimmies rustled.
No jimmies rustled. Just thought the comment was ridiculous due to context. I'm going to put this in college terms based on current rosters. If the NFL were the SEC, Jacksonville's roster could be considered the Vanderbilt. There are zero expectations because everyone and there momma with any sense knows they don't have the team to do it with. Everyone knows they are in complete rebuild right now. Jacksonville would be Iowa St in the Big 12. I'm honestly surprised they have as many wins as they do this year based on their roster alone.
With that said, take any OC you want and put him on Iowa St or Vanderbilt (as the OC, not the HC) and tell me where you would expect their offense to stack up compared to the rest of the conference. Now take those teams and give them a true freshman QB, all freshman WR's, 2 freshman OL with surrounding scrubs, a 3rd year undersized rb and an older slow wanna be power back, and an average tight end who is hurt most of the year. There is not an OC alive who are going to bring those offenses to the top half of their conference or that will even make them respectable in that first season. I'm begging you find me what OC is going to do that.
On top of all that, you have a difference of opinion between the HC and OC. HC wants to be ultra conservative and the OC is uptempo (look at how people think Golden is holding Coley back from what he wants to run).
All of the scenarios you mentioned are not the same as Jacksonville's. yes a 1st pick team and turn it around and become a good team with only a couple of players, but you ceased to mention the fact that they have
Arian Foster, Deandre Hopkins, and Andre Johnson. Their OL is decent as well. They were the 4th best team in the league for sacks allowed. Go ahead and tell me who Jacksonville has even close to the level of any one of those 3 and even if you think you want to compare someone, tell me how many years they've been in the league.
I don't know if I've ever seen a team in Jacksonville's current situation. I've seen rebuilds, but almost every rebuild has something already. Jacksonville might as well be an expansion team right now.