Is Toney the GOAT UM Freshman?

[Stats02]

Lamar miller!

He redshirted his true freshman year, but he was really good his 2nd year as a redshirt freshman.

 

[ssvir]

Bernie Kosar but he was a redshirt

Really chapped my *** when announcers used to refer to guys as Freshman or "set Freshman records" who had been on campus for almost two years

 

[bacane]

Toney has caught passes, run from scrimmage, returned punts and he even passed for a 2-point conversion. Guy does everything.

Parks cars pre-game & helps clean up stadium while rest of team heads back to campus.

 

[SonicYouth]

Duke Johnson was pretty amazing as a true freshman, Bain, Brad Kayaa, Ahmand Richards, Erick Flowers, Mauigoa, Sean Spence...I dont know we've had some guys that balled as a freshman

I saw Ahmand standing on the sidelines next to Michael Irving.

 

[Bird4um]

Is he ALL AMERICAN?

 

[Torocane]

He’s up there. Dude is grit & toughness. So many things he does that might not result in 6, but he gives us that chance. His body control & lower body strength is extremely underrated. He provided us the spark we needed. He did it last week, too, but we played against a much better offensive team that dug too big of a hole.

Forget Freshman All American, he needs to be in the running for an All American spot.

I truly believe that if he played for one of the ESPN chosen schools they would be getting a ton more of attention. At least the same level that the true freshman WR's got last season. JMO

 

[RBradleigh]

Ray Lewis, Dan Morgan, Reggie Wayne, Ahmon Richards were all amazing at true freshman. Not sure they were as important to the team as Toney is to this team. If Toney keeps playing like this, he's probably going down in my book as the player to have the best TF season.

Ray Lewis, Dan Morgan, Reggie Wayne, Ahmon Richards were all amazing at true freshman. Not sure they were as important to the team as Toney is to this team. If Toney keeps playing like this, he's probably going down in my book as the player to have the best TF season.

I had Lewis and Wayne, forgot about Morgan.

 

[Schnelly'sPipe]

He’s climbing the ranks that’s for sure

 

[PIPO]

This team is 4-3 at best without Toney

How is that possible????

Oh, yeah……….

 

[RozayCane]

Any debate left?

 

[Manfred_Cane]

Any debate left?

Once you add that he's 17 or was 17 for a part of this year. Absolutely not

 

[Manfred_Cane]

He'll be an All American and he should win the Shaun Alexander award

 

[dorsey1]

Unequivocally yes!

No freshman in UM history has done what he’s done-

Period-

He’s thy best in our storied yesterday-

He’s been our Cam Ward this year.

 

[FuriousStyles]

Add in he’s a legitimate Punt Returner and not a guy that can catch punts like we’ve had since what seems like forever.

 

[Golsen82]

Keep in mind he should be in HS

Of all time not just Miami. I hope he rushes a td today. Throw catch run

 

[RozayCane]

He'll be an All American and he should win the Shaun Alexander award

I honestly believe he should start getting Heisman votes

 

[cway313]

 

[KANE]

This kid is working himself up everybody’s all time University of Miami greats lists.

 

[atlcane1030]

Yes.

 

[TouchMoney26]

Just broke ahmons record like I said