Are you crazy? What game did you watch? This is beyond laughable.
Walton is a jack of all trades runningback, which means, he doesn't do one thing great but he does everything very good. Which makes him great, he's a top 5 back in his respective class and could probably land a 5th star. Elite just like Scarlett and Dex, who are top 5 in their respective class and can land the possible 5th star too.
I'm sorry op, negged.
You obviously don't watch too much football. Not only that, barring injuries. Walton could be the most complete back of the 4 cause he can do everything.
Scarlett, Walton and Dex. All top 5 in their respective classes, all have the ability to be great.
Scarlett, prototype size, legit burner speed, strong as ****. You can't teach 5'11" 210 4.30 speed and his weight room warrior ability. He's a freak of nature. Already drawing a young Marshawn Lynch or pre-injury McGahee or Trent Richardson comparisons. Scarlett is considered a freakazoid.
Dexter, electric, big already at about 6'0" 195, Very fast, can take off like a jet if he has the hole, electric on the field and hard to be touched. Can catch, can play runningback and receiver and has out of this world athleticism. His Sparq rating was through the roof. Very versatile. Compared to the likes of Jamaal Charles, LeSean McCoy, Percy Harvin, Reggie Bush. But ultimately, he is a offensive weapon, with elite athleticism and ability.
Walton the jack of all trades, doesn't do one thing great, but does everything very good. Which makes him great. Walton about 5'11" 188. Good speed, Physical, He can run, he can catch, can break the tackle, move the chains, can block, can carry his team. Compared to Sony Michel or Emmitt Smith or Matt Forte. A jack of all trades is a RB you really want cause he can be on the field every single down. Walton skillset is what makes him elite.
You know who was a jack of all trades too? Edge. And Edge was a beast.
Maybe you can make a case for Cronk not having the same ceiling, who by the way still puts up great numbers and is a top 15 back in his class. But Cronk has a higher ceiling on defense and could be a great safety instead of just a good runningback.
Your crazy op.