OriginalGatorHater
Sophomore
- Joined
- Jan 14, 2018
- Messages
- 16,956
How do you know he wouldn’t have multiple Super Bowls? These hypotheticals are lazy....no one knows what would happen if we put manning on the patriots or Brady on the ravens or this or that. What we do know is he has 5 rings, has been to 9 Super Bowls and has beaten many teams that are more talented than the pats (like the chiefs last night) He has insane numbers and 12 game winning drives in the playoffs. And pats defenses have been mediocre for a while now and they’re still winning.
Obviously anything could happen, but it is highly unlikely that he would win an SB with the Browns. Especially considering the fact that they wouldn't have all that talent if Brady was there because the team would not finish last year after year.
They are not lazy. This is how you determine the GOAT. You need to hold all factors constant. How would each QB do on identical teams. Whoever would lead the team to the most SBs is the GOAT. Using different teams to compare a player is absolutely ridiculous and laughable. Otherwise we can say Trent Dilfer is better than Marino.
So again I ask. If Brady was on the Browns and performed at an elite level, but won 0 SBs would you still have him in the GOAT conversation? You clearly don't want to answer the question because you know it is going to destroy your whole argument.