forums

Do We Need Alabama or Georgia to LOSE??

JoeToth said:
BYU just played in an extra championship game and they're going to drop out? Surely may not have moved out of the 11th place for the loss but Notre Dame didn't play an extra championship game and they're letting Miami jump over BYU because they lost. Just saying.
Click to expand...
BYU is cheeks, everybody knew it
 
Advertisement
I don’t see how this below is incorrect:
- BAMA blowout was the ideal situation (keeps them above ND and stops the comparison with ND in a pool)
- BAMA blowout loss is the worst situation (they’ll swap them and ND which puts another team between us)
 
YLCANE said:
You dont understand Great 8
How many times do I have to explain it?
Click to expand...

You weren't mentioning great 8 in your post. Only that teams will not be punished by being idle during the CG.

In the committee's rankings, if that applies to Bama then it should apply to BYU as well, regardless of Great 8.
 
The U is back to work said:
I don’t see how this below is incorrect:
- BAMA blowout was the ideal situation (keeps them above ND and stops the comparison with ND in a pool)
- BAMA blowout loss is the worst situation (they’ll swap them and ND which puts another team between us)
Click to expand...
If Bama loses badly enough, it forces the committee to seriously compare us with them... And that FSU common opponent becomes glaring.
 
Cane_Mutiny said:
If Bama loses badly enough, it forces the committee to seriously compare us with them... And that FSU common opponent becomes glaring.
Click to expand...
I just think there’s no chance that happens. They won’t keep Bama out. It’s Bama and the SEC. BYU is easier because it’s BYU and the Big 12. This result sucks for us right now.
 
Advertisement
Cribby said:
This game has me in a pickle . I don’t know what to think or what to do. I’m basically retarded at the current moment
Click to expand...
If there was confidence the committee would drop Bama from 9 to 11 , and BYU from 11 to at leasst 12, then Miami and ND could move up to 9 and 10.

Just no confidence they do that to Bama, no matter how bad the loss.

Someone did the history of the committee and conference championship losers. Everyone dropped at least one spot and many dropped two
 
Hoyacane1620 said:
If there was confidence the committee would drop Bama from 9 to 11 , and BYU from 11 to at leasst 12, then Miami and ND could move up to 9 and 10.

Just no confidence they do that to Bama, no matter how bad the loss.

Someone did the history of the committee and conference championship losers. Everyone dropped at least one spot and many dropped two
Click to expand...
They will drop them one spot, no matter what. ND will be 9 and Bama will be 10.

“We couldn’t compare ND and Miami head to head because Bama was the buffer between them”

Gives the committee an easy out. Many people on this board just don’t get it.
 
My amateur take on this was:

- Best case scenario bama wins, we get right next to ND and head to head has to matter
- Next best case is Bama blowout? They need to drop them, and with an embarrassing blow out it’s hard to say they are better than Miami (but they prob will anyway).

Idk man tell me in retarded or if I’m retarded
 
Advertisement
Hoyacane1620 said:
If there was confidence the committee would drop Bama from 9 to 11 , and BYU from 11 to at leasst 12, then Miami and ND could move up to 9 and 10.

Just no confidence they do that to Bama, no matter how bad the loss.

Someone did the history of the committee and conference championship losers. Everyone dropped at least one spot and many dropped two
Click to expand...
But all that history is from a 4 team playoff. We have last season and only last season as a sample for a 12 team scenario
 
Back
Top