I understand in CIS world if a player isn’t an ALL American by his redshirt freshman season, then that player is a JAG and needs to hit the portal. It just blows my mind how the statements are made from guys who have never been to a practice, had a conversation with anyone on the Miami staff, and has only watched 3 minutes of the kids JR year high school highlights
Players breakout later, in their careers, in new schemes all the time. Look no further than Brashard Smith. As a redshirt sophomore at Miami, Smith had 22 receptions for 263 yards and 2 TDs, 9 carries for 132 rushing yards and 1 TD. As a redshirt JR at SMU when put in a scheme that better fit his skill set as an APB, he thrived. There he rushed for 1,332 yards, 14 TDs, 39 catches for 327 yards and 4 TDs earning 1st team ALL ACC and 3rd team ALL American. So at Miami he was a JAG and at SMU he was an All American, was it the player or the scheme and coaching
How can you judge if a player will ever play when that player has yet to practice a down in the new scheme due to injury? What metrics are you using to make such an absolute determination? Is the thought that players don’t recover from injury or is it more of a new shinny toy on the roster so let’s disregard the old one?
If your talking about how it “supposed” to look, there is not a single player on this roster with Bobby’s combination of size (6-3 230,) speed (runs in the high 4.3 - min 4.4 range) hit power, and ability to rush the passer. Bobby has it all from a traits standpoint, he just couldn’t fully pick up Guidry’s system (like so many other guys on defense). Hetherman’s simple, fast, and aggressive scheme fits his skill set.
I am not saying he will be a starter, I’m saying I don’t think it’s time to write him off. At the end of the day, the beauty of competition is the winner is determined by the ones who are competing and not the ones on the sideline talking.