How many rank teams did bama beat?
How rank teams did FSU beat?
What was bama's SOS?
What was FSU's SOS?
By your logic, Liberty deserves the 4th spot. They are undefeated and conference champ. If that's all it takes, why isn't liberty in the playoffs?
Because you know, just like everyone else, not all undefeated records are the same. Who you play matters and how you beat them matters. OSU lost their QB a couple years ago, went to the Big TEN championship and drop 60 on Wisconsin. Committee took that into consideration, they got in. Rest is history.