MNW's Robinson ready for The Opening

MNW's Robinson ready for The Opening

Peter Ariz
Peter Ariz

Comments (44)

Apparently, he thinks Pete is better situated to determine which players are Miami caliber than our coaching staff is.

Pete is better situated than someone who has never seen these guys play and automatically defers to the coaches.

Of course the coaches are more qualified to evaluate players. This is their profession. But that doesn't mean they're always right. The great thing about increased recruiting coverage and HUDL videos is that fans now have more information to form their own opinions. The boards disagreed with Coker for passing on Santonio Holmes and they killed Shannon for passing on guys like Jayron Hosely and Ryan Shazier. Turns out they were right.

Golden isn't Shannon or Coker, but he's had misses like everyone else. And saying that the "coaching staff knows better" ignores the fact that a coaching staff is not always unanimous on a player.

The point of this board is to give you guys the information to form your own opinions, and the forum to express those opinions.

I have a pretty good idea of how message boards operate and their purpose. The dude asked some kid if a recruit that we took a commitment from is "Miami caliber". I think it's an absurd question to ask of a guy who is probably 19 years old and has zero experience building a football roster. Ask him if looked big or what his numbers are or what he said to him. I just get a chuckle when football fans feel the need to ax another football fan to tell him if a guy is a good player.

I agree with you that there is plenty of information out there available for fans to look at and that The Don is far from infallible. But if I had to put my money on The Don or on Pete Aziz when it comes to selecting football players to attend UM I'm **** sure going with The Don. Digius has probably been watching football longer than Pete has. He should form his own opinion.
 
Apparently, he thinks Pete is better situated to determine which players are Miami caliber than our coaching staff is.

Pete is better situated than someone who has never seen these guys play and automatically defers to the coaches.

Of course the coaches are more qualified to evaluate players. This is their profession. But that doesn't mean they're always right. The great thing about increased recruiting coverage and HUDL videos is that fans now have more information to form their own opinions. The boards disagreed with Coker for passing on Santonio Holmes and they killed Shannon for passing on guys like Jayron Hosely and Ryan Shazier. Turns out they were right.

Golden isn't Shannon or Coker, but he's had misses like everyone else. And saying that the "coaching staff knows better" ignores the fact that a coaching staff is not always unanimous on a player.

The point of this board is to give you guys the information to form your own opinions, and the forum to express those opinions.

I have a pretty good idea of how message boards operate and their purpose. The dude asked some kid if a recruit that we took a commitment from is "Miami caliber". I think it's an absurd question to ask of a guy who is probably 19 years old and has zero experience building a football roster. Ask him if looked big or what his numbers are or what he said to him. I just get a chuckle when football fans feel the need to ax another football fan to tell him if a guy is a good player.

I agree with you that there is plenty of information out there available for fans to look at and that The Don is far from infallible. But if I had to put my money on The Don or on Pete Aziz when it comes to selecting football players to attend UM I'm **** sure going with The Don. Digius has probably been watching football longer than Pete has. He should form his own opinion.

Look, I asked the guy because he just saw a 7 vs 7 tournament with Mayes in attendance and I wanted to ask his opinion, nothing less nothing more. I really can't form an opinion on a kid that I dont have much info on. There isn't much tape on him and he came from a small school that does not get much recognition from scouts. You say that I'm a million miles from striking a nerve yet a simple question caused reply after reply to it. Stop trying to always over think things and stop trying to be the smartest guy in the room.

Maybe you got your feathers ruffled by the 'Miami caliber' comment, sorry I could have worded it better o warden of canesinsight. I know I'm not the only person that has questions about the kid. That is not saying I don't think the kid is good or I seriously question the staff's decision, im trying to form an opinion as you insinuated I should. I don't live SF, I don't get to see these kids live like you might so I had the audacity to ask someone that did Im sorry I thought this board was for discussion about Miami football......
 
Apparently, he thinks Pete is better situated to determine which players are Miami caliber than our coaching staff is.

Pete is better situated than someone who has never seen these guys play and automatically defers to the coaches.

Of course the coaches are more qualified to evaluate players. This is their profession. But that doesn't mean they're always right. The great thing about increased recruiting coverage and HUDL videos is that fans now have more information to form their own opinions. The boards disagreed with Coker for passing on Santonio Holmes and they killed Shannon for passing on guys like Jayron Hosely and Ryan Shazier. Turns out they were right.

Golden isn't Shannon or Coker, but he's had misses like everyone else. And saying that the "coaching staff knows better" ignores the fact that a coaching staff is not always unanimous on a player.

The point of this board is to give you guys the information to form your own opinions, and the forum to express those opinions.

I have a pretty good idea of how message boards operate and their purpose. The dude asked some kid if a recruit that we took a commitment from is "Miami caliber". I think it's an absurd question to ask of a guy who is probably 19 years old and has zero experience building a football roster. Ask him if looked big or what his numbers are or what he said to him. I just get a chuckle when football fans feel the need to ax another football fan to tell him if a guy is a good player.

I agree with you that there is plenty of information out there available for fans to look at and that The Don is far from infallible. But if I had to put my money on The Don or on Pete Aziz when it comes to selecting football players to attend UM I'm **** sure going with The Don. Digius has probably been watching football longer than Pete has. He should form his own opinion.

Look, I asked the guy because he just saw a 7 vs 7 tournament with Mayes in attendance and I wanted to ask his opinion, nothing less nothing more. I really can't form an opinion on a kid that I dont have much info on. There isn't much tape on him and he came from a small school that does not get much recognition from scouts. You say that I'm a million miles from striking a nerve yet a simple question caused reply after reply to it. Stop trying to always over think things and stop trying to be the smartest guy in the room.

Maybe you got your feathers ruffled by the 'Miami caliber' comment, sorry I could have worded it better o warden of canesinsight. I know I'm not the only person that has questions about the kid. That is not saying I don't think the kid is good or I seriously question the staff's decision, im trying to form an opinion as you insinuated I should. I don't live SF, I don't get to see these kids live like you might so I had the audacity to ask someone that did Im sorry I thought this board was for discussion about Miami football......

It's over now. Keep trying to perpetuate it if you'd like, but it's over.
 
You know what Bobbydigius..I respect you for admitting that because you havent seen the kid play yet..you are not qualified to form an educated opinion. Instead of being like MANY MANY posters on here who pretend to see these kids and form stupid opinions which are more then likely WRONG, you deferred to someone who has. I can respect that. More posters on here could learn from that. I grow very tired of reading posts from guys who watch a 5min clip of a kid off youtube and think they can form an opinion. Smh. How bout go see the kid live then come holla at the board..So as the jamaicans say...Respect.
 
Advertisement
Back
Top