I truly think some of you guys are out of your minds. We cannot waste a championship defense on Perry --a true freshman --that did not play in a sophisticated offense in HS. There is a zero % chance that guy comes in to win the job after missing the spring---ZERO!!
He needs to redshirt, learn the system, enhance his footwork, and learn to read defenses at this level. We must play the best guy, and the besst guy will be either Rosier, Sherrifs or perhaps even Allison, in order to try to win the ACC and perhaps have a shot at the playoffs.
If we start Perry we will have wasted this championship caliber defense. Cannot happen! That's the kind of **** Al Golden would do.
We must try to win NOW!
"Wasting a championship defense on Perry."
I wonder were Bama fans saying the same thing about starting Jalen Hurts this year. He was a true freshman this past season. Granted, I believe he was an EE, but still a true freshman.
If that's the case, then none of his selections should be trusted, Rosier, Perry, Shirreffs & Sitkow included.Rick picked a lot of ****** QBs at UGA. He's no miracle QB selector. Good thing Perry is going to hit the ground running and have no learning curve because Rick picked him.
Rick signed Rosier and Shirreffs? When it comes to the QB spot, I need to see them do it while the band is playing.
HS accolades are nice, and Perry is a great talent. But so was Kenny Kelly, and he struggled badly. And he didn't get forced into starting as a true freshmans. A far less talented Dorsey eventually stole his lunch money and made him a minor league baseball player.
This is a whole other level of football when it comes to playing QB. There is so much thinking and information processing that goes into playing QB for Rick that it's almost foolish to think that Perry will come in and win the job in a month. A lot of dudes on here set Allison up too. Now, he's a bum.
thank you, franchise.
your post should be taped to the forehead of every slurper who thinks: 4.4 40 + strong arm + HS hype = immediate QB stardom
greatness at QB starts between the ears.
what do Kosar, Walsh, Dorsey, Erickson, and Torretta all have in common? Besides great talent around them? they were whip smart at the position.
oh, and another thing they all have in common: championship rings ...
hmmm Brad Kaaya was the smartest QB in cfb the last 3 years yet we still sucked???
and hilarious how you act like those qbs that won QBs on loaded teams were geniuses??? gtfoh
If that's the case, then none of his selections should be trusted, Rosier, Perry, Shirreffs & Sitkow included.It's better for us that its the QB Richt picked, he has trained the offense to Perry's strengths.
Rick picked a lot of ****** QBs at UGA. He's no miracle QB selector. Good thing Perry is going to hit the ground running and have no learning curve because Rick picked him.
Rick signed Rosier and Shirreffs? When it comes to the QB spot, I need to see them do it while the band is playing.
HS accolades are nice, and Perry is a great talent. But so was Kenny Kelly, and he struggled badly. And he didn't get forced into starting as a true freshmans. A far less talented Dorsey eventually stole his lunch money and made him a minor league baseball player.
This is a whole other level of football when it comes to playing QB. There is so much thinking and information processing that goes into playing QB for Rick that it's almost foolish to think that Perry will come in and win the job in a month. A lot of dudes on here set Allison up too. Now, he's a bum.
If that's the case, then none of his selections should be trusted, Rosier, Perry, Shirreffs & Sitkow included.It's better for us that its the QB Richt picked, he has trained the offense to Perry's strengths.
Rick picked a lot of ****** QBs at UGA. He's no miracle QB selector. Good thing Perry is going to hit the ground running and have no learning curve because Rick picked him.
Rick signed Rosier and Shirreffs? When it comes to the QB spot, I need to see them do it while the band is playing.
HS accolades are nice, and Perry is a great talent. But so was Kenny Kelly, and he struggled badly. And he didn't get forced into starting as a true freshmans. A far less talented Dorsey eventually stole his lunch money and made him a minor league baseball player.
This is a whole other level of football when it comes to playing QB. There is so much thinking and information processing that goes into playing QB for Rick that it's almost foolish to think that Perry will come in and win the job in a month. A lot of dudes on here set Allison up too. Now, he's a bum.
thank you, franchise.
your post should be taped to the forehead of every slurper who thinks: 4.4 40 + strong arm + HS hype = immediate QB stardom
greatness at QB starts between the ears.
what do Kosar, Walsh, Dorsey, Erickson, and Torretta all have in common? Besides great talent around them? they were whip smart at the position.
oh, and another thing they all have in common: championship rings ...
If that's the case, then none of his selections should be trusted, Rosier, Perry, Shirreffs & Sitkow included.It's better for us that its the QB Richt picked, he has trained the offense to Perry's strengths.
Rick picked a lot of ****** QBs at UGA. He's no miracle QB selector. Good thing Perry is going to hit the ground running and have no learning curve because Rick picked him.
Rick signed Rosier and Shirreffs? When it comes to the QB spot, I need to see them do it while the band is playing.
HS accolades are nice, and Perry is a great talent. But so was Kenny Kelly, and he struggled badly. And he didn't get forced into starting as a true freshmans. A far less talented Dorsey eventually stole his lunch money and made him a minor league baseball player.
This is a whole other level of football when it comes to playing QB. There is so much thinking and information processing that goes into playing QB for Rick that it's almost foolish to think that Perry will come in and win the job in a month. A lot of dudes on here set Allison up too. Now, he's a bum.
Kenny says that was the worst decision he ever made. Wish he would've stayed.
So did I.
If that's the case, then none of his selections should be trusted, Rosier, Perry, Shirreffs & Sitkow included.Rick picked a lot of ****** QBs at UGA. He's no miracle QB selector. Good thing Perry is going to hit the ground running and have no learning curve because Rick picked him.
Rick signed Rosier and Shirreffs? When it comes to the QB spot, I need to see them do it while the band is playing.
HS accolades are nice, and Perry is a great talent. But so was Kenny Kelly, and he struggled badly. And he didn't get forced into starting as a true freshmans. A far less talented Dorsey eventually stole his lunch money and made him a minor league baseball player.
This is a whole other level of football when it comes to playing QB. There is so much thinking and information processing that goes into playing QB for Rick that it's almost foolish to think that Perry will come in and win the job in a month. A lot of dudes on here set Allison up too. Now, he's a bum.
thank you, franchise.
your post should be taped to the forehead of every slurper who thinks: 4.4 40 + strong arm + HS hype = immediate QB stardom
greatness at QB starts between the ears.
what do Kosar, Walsh, Dorsey, Erickson, and Torretta all have in common? Besides great talent around them? they were whip smart at the position.
oh, and another thing they all have in common: championship rings ...
Guys get too juiced up over HS highlights from QBs. QB is a totally different animal than any other position on the field. Your QB must know everything he has to do and everything everyone else is doing on every **** play. He is the leader of the offense. If your QB gets in the huddle and doesn't know what's going, it's impossible for him to be an effective leader.
I love Perry's talent. I love Weldon's talent too. They're both physically better talents than anyone else on the roster. Problem is that the game speeds up by a thousand times when you're not comfortable and sure of everything. On top of that, Rick expects his QBs to be perfect and to always make the right read. Great talent like Perry's gets equalized if he's unsure and is thinking too much.
Dudes are expecting way too much from him as a late entry. I'd love to see a list of summer enrollee true freshmans QBs who have started and won conference/national championships. I'm guessing it's a microscopic list of QBs.
I truly think some of you guys are out of your minds. We cannot waste a championship defense on Perry --a true freshman --that did not play in a sophisticated offense in HS. There is a zero % chance that guy comes in to win the job after missing the spring---ZERO!!
He needs to redshirt, learn the system, enhance his footwork, and learn to read defenses at this level. We must play the best guy, and the besst guy will be either Rosier, Sherrifs or perhaps even Allison, in order to try to win the ACC and perhaps have a shot at the playoffs.
If we start Perry we will have wasted this championship caliber defense. Cannot happen! That's the kind of **** Al Golden would do.
We must try to win NOW!
It might get wasted with sheriifs or rosier too. Doesnt matter how old the qb is the best guy should start.
If that's the case, then none of his selections should be trusted, Rosier, Perry, Shirreffs & Sitkow included.
Rick signed Rosier and Shirreffs? When it comes to the QB spot, I need to see them do it while the band is playing.
HS accolades are nice, and Perry is a great talent. But so was Kenny Kelly, and he struggled badly. And he didn't get forced into starting as a true freshmans. A far less talented Dorsey eventually stole his lunch money and made him a minor league baseball player.
This is a whole other level of football when it comes to playing QB. There is so much thinking and information processing that goes into playing QB for Rick that it's almost foolish to think that Perry will come in and win the job in a month. A lot of dudes on here set Allison up too. Now, he's a bum.
thank you, franchise.
your post should be taped to the forehead of every slurper who thinks: 4.4 40 + strong arm + HS hype = immediate QB stardom
greatness at QB starts between the ears.
what do Kosar, Walsh, Dorsey, Erickson, and Torretta all have in common? Besides great talent around them? they were whip smart at the position.
oh, and another thing they all have in common: championship rings ...
Guys get too juiced up over HS highlights from QBs. QB is a totally different animal than any other position on the field. Your QB must know everything he has to do and everything everyone else is doing on every **** play. He is the leader of the offense. If your QB gets in the huddle and doesn't know what's going, it's impossible for him to be an effective leader.
I love Perry's talent. I love Weldon's talent too. They're both physically better talents than anyone else on the roster. Problem is that the game speeds up by a thousand times when you're not comfortable and sure of everything. On top of that, Rick expects his QBs to be perfect and to always make the right read. Great talent like Perry's gets equalized if he's unsure and is thinking too much.
Dudes are expecting way too much from him as a late entry. I'd love to see a list of summer enrollee true freshmans QBs who have started and won conference/national championships. I'm guessing it's a microscopic list of QBs.
I looked this up a little while ago. It's a small list and most of the ones on it had 8 or 9 wins tops. Hurts would certainly be on the list, but he's more of a running back playing quarterback.
True freshman QBs who led teams to the best seasons. | Sports on Earth
Rick signed Rosier and Shirreffs? When it comes to the QB spot, I need to see them do it while the band is playing.
HS accolades are nice, and Perry is a great talent. But so was Kenny Kelly, and he struggled badly. And he didn't get forced into starting as a true freshmans. A far less talented Dorsey eventually stole his lunch money and made him a minor league baseball player.
This is a whole other level of football when it comes to playing QB. There is so much thinking and information processing that goes into playing QB for Rick that it's almost foolish to think that Perry will come in and win the job in a month. A lot of dudes on here set Allison up too. Now, he's a bum.
thank you, franchise.
your post should be taped to the forehead of every slurper who thinks: 4.4 40 + strong arm + HS hype = immediate QB stardom
greatness at QB starts between the ears.
what do Kosar, Walsh, Dorsey, Erickson, and Torretta all have in common? Besides great talent around them? they were whip smart at the position.
oh, and another thing they all have in common: championship rings ...
Guys get too juiced up over HS highlights from QBs. QB is a totally different animal than any other position on the field. Your QB must know everything he has to do and everything everyone else is doing on every **** play. He is the leader of the offense. If your QB gets in the huddle and doesn't know what's going, it's impossible for him to be an effective leader.
I love Perry's talent. I love Weldon's talent too. They're both physically better talents than anyone else on the roster. Problem is that the game speeds up by a thousand times when you're not comfortable and sure of everything. On top of that, Rick expects his QBs to be perfect and to always make the right read. Great talent like Perry's gets equalized if he's unsure and is thinking too much.
Dudes are expecting way too much from him as a late entry. I'd love to see a list of summer enrollee true freshmans QBs who have started and won conference/national championships. I'm guessing it's a microscopic list of QBs.
I looked this up a little while ago. It's a small list and most of the ones on it had 8 or 9 wins tops. Hurts would certainly be on the list, but he's more of a running back playing quarterback.
True freshman QBs who led teams to the best seasons. | Sports on Earth
Thanks, JohnnyB. I don't think Hurts was a summer enrollee though. I'd think the list of summer enrollees who won championships as true freshmans would be even shorter.
I don't know about you guys, but I ain't looking to win 8 or 9 games this year. If we don't win at least 10 regular season games and play for the ACC championship, then this season is a fail.
There's nothing left to argue on the matter, it'll be Rosier or Shirreffs...
We'll find out what they're made of on 9/16 & 10/28.
[MENTION=4841]The Franchise[/MENTION] No need to get upset my friend. Sometimes your sarcasm doesn't register immediately. It's not that important.Yeah but Perry can throw it 67 yards and Rick compared him to Charlie Ward who started from day one as a true freshmans at FSU.I see this playing out very similar to 3 yrs ago when Kaaya got here. If one of the guys already on campus separate themselves and takes charge it's their job. If no one really shows out, Perry will have a legit shot to come in and show what he's got. If he can be on par with or very close he could win the job.
He could still win the job, but because he's a not-early-enrolling freshmans, I personally believe the odds are low.
This is NOTHING like Bard's freshmans year. The projected starter doesn't have a shredded knee.
Ward redshirted his second year in Tally(1990). I'm sure of it. Also Ward was a true freshman in 89 and did not get any meaningful playing time until he won the job in 92 his 4th year in the program.
No ****.
If that's the case, then none of his selections should be trusted, Rosier, Perry, Shirreffs & Sitkow included.Rick picked a lot of ****** QBs at UGA. He's no miracle QB selector. Good thing Perry is going to hit the ground running and have no learning curve because Rick picked him.
Rick signed Rosier and Shirreffs? When it comes to the QB spot, I need to see them do it while the band is playing.
HS accolades are nice, and Perry is a great talent. But so was Kenny Kelly, and he struggled badly. And he didn't get forced into starting as a true freshmans. A far less talented Dorsey eventually stole his lunch money and made him a minor league baseball player.
This is a whole other level of football when it comes to playing QB. There is so much thinking and information processing that goes into playing QB for Rick that it's almost foolish to think that Perry will come in and win the job in a month. A lot of dudes on here set Allison up too. Now, he's a bum.
thank you, franchise.
your post should be taped to the forehead of every slurper who thinks: 4.4 40 + strong arm + HS hype = immediate QB stardom
greatness at QB starts between the ears.
what do Kosar, Walsh, Dorsey, Erickson, and Torretta all have in common? Besides great talent around them? they were whip smart at the position.
oh, and another thing they all have in common: championship rings ...
Guys get too juiced up over HS highlights from QBs. QB is a totally different animal than any other position on the field. Your QB must know everything he has to do and everything everyone else is doing on every **** play. He is the leader of the offense. If your QB gets in the huddle and doesn't know what's going, it's impossible for him to be an effective leader.
I love Perry's talent. I love Weldon's talent too. They're both physically better talents than anyone else on the roster. Problem is that the game speeds up by a thousand times when you're not comfortable and sure of everything. On top of that, Rick expects his QBs to be perfect and to always make the right read. Great talent like Perry's gets equalized if he's unsure and is thinking too much.
Dudes are expecting way too much from him as a late entry. I'd love to see a list of summer enrollee true freshmans QBs who have started and won conference/national championships. I'm guessing it's a microscopic list of QBs.
Yeah but Perry can throw it 67 yards and Rick compared him to Charlie Ward who started from day one as a true freshmans at FSU.I see this playing out very similar to 3 yrs ago when Kaaya got here. If one of the guys already on campus separate themselves and takes charge it's their job. If no one really shows out, Perry will have a legit shot to come in and show what he's got. If he can be on par with or very close he could win the job.
He could still win the job, but because he's a not-early-enrolling freshmans, I personally believe the odds are low.
This is NOTHING like Bard's freshmans year. The projected starter doesn't have a shredded knee.
Yes, Charlie Ward started day one as a true freshman--as the punter. Peter Tom Willis started the entire year in 1989. Ward redshirted in 1990. Weldon platooned with Brad Johnson in 1990 and was the full-time starter in 1991. Ward didn't start until 1992.
For Perry to start in my opinion, he needs to be clearly better than Rosier and Shirreffs by the second week in fall camp and by an extremely wide margin. Or the latter two need to be mediocre at best. We'll see.
No, Casey Weldon was the full time starter in 91.
thank you, franchise.
your post should be taped to the forehead of every slurper who thinks: 4.4 40 + strong arm + HS hype = immediate QB stardom
greatness at QB starts between the ears.
what do Kosar, Walsh, Dorsey, Erickson, and Torretta all have in common? Besides great talent around them? they were whip smart at the position.
oh, and another thing they all have in common: championship rings ...
Guys get too juiced up over HS highlights from QBs. QB is a totally different animal than any other position on the field. Your QB must know everything he has to do and everything everyone else is doing on every **** play. He is the leader of the offense. If your QB gets in the huddle and doesn't know what's going, it's impossible for him to be an effective leader.
I love Perry's talent. I love Weldon's talent too. They're both physically better talents than anyone else on the roster. Problem is that the game speeds up by a thousand times when you're not comfortable and sure of everything. On top of that, Rick expects his QBs to be perfect and to always make the right read. Great talent like Perry's gets equalized if he's unsure and is thinking too much.
Dudes are expecting way too much from him as a late entry. I'd love to see a list of summer enrollee true freshmans QBs who have started and won conference/national championships. I'm guessing it's a microscopic list of QBs.
I looked this up a little while ago. It's a small list and most of the ones on it had 8 or 9 wins tops. Hurts would certainly be on the list, but he's more of a running back playing quarterback.
True freshman QBs who led teams to the best seasons. | Sports on Earth
Thanks, JohnnyB. I don't think Hurts was a summer enrollee though. I'd think the list of summer enrollees who won championships as true freshmans would be even shorter.
I don't know about you guys, but I ain't looking to win 8 or 9 games this year. If we don't win at least 10 regular season games and play for the ACC championship, then this season is a fail.
sheriffs or rosier doesnt guarantee a 10 win season. These dudes are bridge qbs. Basically like what maguire was at fsu. One of them will start to give the younger more talented qbs the chance to get ready.
It's a game of odds and probabilities. Rick knows he should have a great defense this year and can make a big move with this team THIS YEAR if his QB can hit some easy passes, distribute the ball and not make a lot of dumb freshmans mistakes.
Guys get too juiced up over HS highlights from QBs. QB is a totally different animal than any other position on the field. Your QB must know everything he has to do and everything everyone else is doing on every **** play. He is the leader of the offense. If your QB gets in the huddle and doesn't know what's going, it's impossible for him to be an effective leader.
I love Perry's talent. I love Weldon's talent too. They're both physically better talents than anyone else on the roster. Problem is that the game speeds up by a thousand times when you're not comfortable and sure of everything. On top of that, Rick expects his QBs to be perfect and to always make the right read. Great talent like Perry's gets equalized if he's unsure and is thinking too much.
Dudes are expecting way too much from him as a late entry. I'd love to see a list of summer enrollee true freshmans QBs who have started and won conference/national championships. I'm guessing it's a microscopic list of QBs.
I looked this up a little while ago. It's a small list and most of the ones on it had 8 or 9 wins tops. Hurts would certainly be on the list, but he's more of a running back playing quarterback.
True freshman QBs who led teams to the best seasons. | Sports on Earth
Thanks, JohnnyB. I don't think Hurts was a summer enrollee though. I'd think the list of summer enrollees who won championships as true freshmans would be even shorter.
I don't know about you guys, but I ain't looking to win 8 or 9 games this year. If we don't win at least 10 regular season games and play for the ACC championship, then this season is a fail.
sheriffs or rosier doesnt guarantee a 10 win season. These dudes are bridge qbs. Basically like what maguire was at fsu. One of them will start to give the younger more talented qbs the chance to get ready.
No QB guarantees anything. You're constantly talking to me about guarantees when you've never seen me mention anything about guarantees.
It's a game of odds and probabilities. Rick knows he should have a great defense this year and can make a big move with this team THIS YEAR if his QB can hit some easy passes, distribute the ball and not make a lot of dumb freshmans mistakes.
Rick has a chance to have an excellent season, and he's going to play the odds. The odds are that a veteran QB with less talent can make less killer mistakes and cost the team less games. Anything else would be a major disservice to the rest of the team.