I'm going to go ahead and change the rules a little. Too many all-time greats to do not do it by position. So, here's my Miami Rushmore by position: (based solely on career at Miami)
QB - Vinny, Bernie, Gino & Dorsey
RB - Edge, Portis, Highsmith & Ottis Anderson
WR - Irvin, Andre Johnson, Reggie & Lamar
TE - Winslow, Shockey, Bubba & Olsen
OL - McKinnie, Searcy, Romberg & Carey
DT - Jerome, Sapp, Russell Maryland & Cortez
DE - Stubbs, Hendricks, Greg Mark & McDougle
ILB - Ray Lewis, Morgan, Barrow & Vilma
OLB - Jessie, Darrin Smith, DJ & Beason
CB - Antrell, Rumph, Buchanon & McNeil
S - Ed, 26, Bennie & Meriweather
ST - Hester, Feagles, Huerta & Kevin Williams
HC - Jimmy, Schelly, Botch & Manolo (I kid. Jury is still out). Gotta go with Dennis Erickson. Only coach to win 2 nattys