I am big on Schiano because I watched a lot of his games at Rutgers. He excelled at all the criteria I like in a coach: Well organized, can recruit, excellent game day coach, always a trick up his sleeve, great developer, knows his ****, physical teams, very competitive teams.
Remember it was Rutgers. I believe he would be a equivalent of Saban here at the U and would be successful keeping recruits home. Also his coaches will know their ****.
I'm a Butch guy first too, but if we want to change styles and go younger then Herman and leave it there.