What you just said echoes the academy and travel soccer mentality of competition and coaching that got us to the current shty *** status quo of entitled soccer players that complain about bad fields while South American kids are playing barefoot, uphill on asphalt full of potholes. The local teams play futsal on basketball courts and the better players play on dirt with hand me down cleats and equipment. Only the best of the best get called to play (for free) on good grass with new boots and uniforms (again for free) if they’ve proven they can be the best players form what’s left of the poor and the rich and everyone in between. I’m 48 and my kid is 8. I’ve played in high school In the 80’s and I’ve been following youth soccer here for a while. The academy kids are spoiled and entitled and think their sht don’t stink cause they can wear their academy gear all over town and tell stories about how they played in some tournament in Brazil or Europe. The parents all think their kid is the next Messi. The system is full of entitled kids who’s parents even pay for private lessons and it still hasn’t worked. You need numbers and eventually you’ll find the talent.
Your right, the mls and the ECNL are already gonna take all those clubs and nothing will change. I will say this. The level of play at the u10 level all over this country right now is pretty **** good. My kid not included he’s struggling to stay on the team.
When I see the 14 year olds play and then watch the level of 8-10 year olds I can assure you that they will be leaps ahead of What we have now in this country but idk of it will be enough.
Yes, playing good competition helps. But the travel and academy teams aren’t all that competitive if all you have are kids that could pay. Ive seen kids that can play in any travel team down here but the parents can’t pay and work a lot to make ends meet and can’t take them to practice. A school team would be perfect for tons of kids that fit that description. Trust me,there are tons of kids like that in this country that in the past would be playing against all the travel and academy kids but they would be playing with or against them in school. So at the youth level there are likely thousands of kids that could bench travel team players and we don’t know about it and aren’t developing them.