While Wimbush is certainly the more polished QB at the moment, no QB prospect in the country has the mutant like physical ability and athleticism that Gibson possesses. Its truly abnormal. Gibson does not have to play right away with the likes of Olsen/HBK on the roster. He can redshirt and hone his craft and technique. In other words, he is the perfect replacement for those two.
Wimbush is a guy that is ready to play right now and he is more likely to do that at a place like Ohio St than beat out a more experienced Olsen/HBK as a true freshmen. I'm also inclined to be more rustled to lose a player in your proximity over a kid located in B1G country. "God put Savages in South Florida For You and Me!!" (Chris Tucker Voice)
So in closing, Give me this Usain Bolt look alike or give me death.