Agree 100%. If we had McGahee in OT we definitely score at the end. Not to mention that he had just started to wear down the OSU defense when he was hurt.Bruh; I would contend that had McGahee not gotten hurt, not only do we win the Nat’l Championship, it was a guarantee he was going top 5, and I would assume he would’ve put up 10k+ in his career. Even though he had a productive career, he still wasn’t that explosive back like he was...YET he still won the Come Back Player of The Year, and made multiple pro bowls. Willis was a special back. He & Gore r the what ifs w/o those knee injuries.
McGahee had a chance to be the best ever from the U in the league, which is a high bar and requires longevity because of Anderson, Edge and Gore. And you are absolutely correct that he was still productive in the league but he was never as explosive as he was in college.