forums

Richt on the qb order



Think any other qb we have has this in their game?? Nah, ****, no other qb we ever had possessed this type of quickness, agility, and escapabiliy.
This is a different game now, and you have to be able to move and throw.
 
Advertisement
Texxcane said:
Hater, I agree and have said so many times. Right knows **** good and well Rosier is weak link on offense, he will keep him as starter to keep him from going anywhere. He will start at LSU, he will be on a short hook though, this year he actually has other options. Not gonna compete in the QB contraversy on this board however, all I will say is we have 3 legit guys now, I trust Richt will go with the one that gives him the best chance to win. I know it’s hard for some on here but MR knows more about the position than any CIS board member. His hands has been tied since he got here, this year it’s not the case, I know he must feel good about that, finally
Click to expand...



Agree 100% Texx. Don't really care who looked great in practice today or tomorrow. I'm going to relax until gametime.

During any game, CMR "will go with the one that gives him the best chance to win"

The great thing is that we no longer HAVE TO endure or wait out lackadaisical, or poor QB game performance.

Now we have viable options and I'm sure CMR will use them if/when he has to without hesitation.
 
Last edited:
Loose Cannon said:
I've seen many reports that Cade Weldon is more athletic and more dynamic than Nkosi Perry. Petrino was platooning because he did not have a returning Senior coming off a 10 win season, a berth in the conference championship, and a NY6 appearance. He was platooning because even WITH a Heisman Trophy winner under center Louisville is an 8-5, 9-4, 8-5 team. He's platooning because he can. He's platooning because 8-5 and a losing effort in the Belk Bowl is acceptable at Louisville. We would fire Richt if at the end of three seasons, a 9-4 record with a win in the Music City bowl was his best season. We won 10 games last year. We're not about to "throw Perry to the wolves" and hope for the best. We're likely going to be favored in at least 10, if not all, of our games. Only an absolute idiot would gamble with an unknown quantity.
Click to expand...
Its a HUGE gamble to go with a qb who should never take another snap in a CANES uniform. 10 wins is not a guarantee with an inconsistent, inaccurate, one-read qb. If you really want to be honest; we should have lost 3 more games last year. The TO chain contributed more than #12 did in those wins. From the staff/players, it seems that this years version Perry is capable of winning 10-12(considering the schedule)and a better result in the acccg. Those games last year should have been blowouts. #12 was outplayed by every qb we faced last year except ND. ****, if Petrino had what we had at qb last year; yeah, he would throw Perry/Weldon/Williams to the wolves if they showed any glimpse of readiness. **** nah to #12 and his bs. Stick around and be a backup with experience since everyone else is young.
 
Milkcane said:
Just keep watching, you'll see he has plenty of both.
Click to expand...
The people who have been watching, the coaches and others who have had the opportunity to view the practices and scrimmages have said that he is lacking in one of those and nothing "elite" in the other.

He's behind Rosier for a reason, and it ain't because Richt won't "throw him out there."
 
Milkcane said:


Think any other qb we have has this in their game?? Nah, ****, no other qb we ever had possessed this type of quickness, agility, and escapabiliy.
This is a different game now, and you have to be able to move and throw.
Click to expand...

Why would I want a QB who can escape a perfectly clean pocket. He stepped up and let the ends go by, just like you're taught to do. Then he just ran for no apparent reason out of a clean pocket right into the defender who had QB responsibility on the play. Leaving a clean pocket without ever looking downfield isn't escapability. It's stupidity. If he meets any P5 1st string linebacker he gets leveled. As it were, he met Derrion Owens who transferred to G5 Houston because he lost his 2nd string spot.
 
Milkcane said:


Think any other qb we have has this in their game?? Nah, ****, no other qb we ever had possessed this type of quickness, agility, and escapabiliy.
This is a different game now, and you have to be able to move and throw.
Click to expand...

One play in practice means he can run the O, go through progressions, hit guys in stride, and generally make good decisions with the ball in his hands. If juke moves is all it takes to play QB, why the heck didn't we play Devin Hester at QB?
 
404CANES said:
Its a HUGE gamble to go with a qb who should never take another snap in a CANES uniform. 10 wins is not a guarantee with an inconsistent, inaccurate, one-read qb. If you really want to be honest; we should have lost 3 more games last year. The TO chain contributed more than #12 did in those wins. From the staff/players, it seems that this years version Perry is capable of winning 10-12(considering the schedule)and a better result in the acccg. Those games last year should have been blowouts. #12 was outplayed by every qb we faced last year except ND. ****, if Petrino had what we had at qb last year; yeah, he would throw Perry/Weldon/Williams to the wolves if they showed any glimpse of readiness. **** nah to #12 and his bs. Stick around and be a backup with experience since everyone else is young.
Click to expand...


Now I'm confused. Is your beef because we have Nkosi Perry at QB instead of Lamar Jackson, or that we have Mark Richt as HC instead of Bobby Patrino?

"From the staff/players, it seems that this years version Perry is capable of winning 10-12(considering the schedule)and a better result in the acccg"

So 10 wins is not guaranteed with a guy who's done it, yet 10-12 is with a guy who's never taken a snap? And just stop it with the "he doesn't have any experience because CMR wouldn't play him," bull****. The guy who in your mind doesn't deserve another snap beat out and is still ahead of the guy you think should be starting because he's earned it. If and when Nkosi EARNS the job he'll get his chance, but it will not be because you or any other porsters here don't think Rosier deserves another snap.
 
Loose Cannon said:
Now I'm confused. Is your beef because we have Nkosi Perry at QB instead of Lamar Jackson, or that we have Mark Richt as HC instead of Bobby Patrino?

"From the staff/players, it seems that this years version Perry is capable of winning 10-12(considering the schedule)and a better result in the acccg"

So 10 wins is not guaranteed with a guy who's done it, yet 10-12 is with a guy who's never taken a snap? And just stop it with the "he doesn't have any experience because CMR wouldn't play him," bull****. The guy who in your mind doesn't deserve another snap beat out and is still ahead of the guy you think should be starting because he's earned it. If and when Nkosi EARNS the job he'll get his chance, but it will not be because you or any other porsters here don't think Rosier deserves another snap.
Click to expand...
Reading comprehension is so underrated...Dude, this is spring camp. In regards to Perry being behind #12 bc he hasn't earned it is your opinion. Hurts is #1 in bama"s spring camp followed by Tua and you're going to tell me he hasn't earned it. Stop acting like you have access to CMR coaches and/or qb meetings. You don't know what the he11 is going on behind closed doors and screened fences. Im debating with someone whose giving #12 credit for 10 wins a year ago. Anyone with any IQ of football and watched all our games in '17 would boldly stand in disagreement to your claim. We won in spite of that guy under center. You're here just as a fan i assume. You come on and get your lil updates and meet others that rep The U. Let those who know the game and this team share words of wisdom while you just react.
 
404CANES said:
Reading comprehension is so underrated...Dude, this is spring camp. In regards to Perry being behind #12 bc he hasn't earned it is your opinion. Hurts is #1 in bama"s spring camp followed by Tua and you're going to tell me he hasn't earned it. Stop acting like you have access to CMR coaches and/or qb meetings. You don't know what the he11 is going on behind closed doors and screened fences. Im debating with someone whose giving #12 credit for 10 wins a year ago. Anyone with any IQ of football and watched all our games in '17 would boldly stand in disagreement to your claim. We won in spite of that guy under center. You're here just as a fan i assume. You come on and get your lil updates and meet others that rep The U. Let those who know the game and this team share words of wisdom while you just react.
Click to expand...

That's actually the opinion of the coaches, it would seem. I believe it was Richt Flair who said on Friday that to be the man you got to beat the man. Wasn't it OC Thomas Brown who just yesterday said that it's Rosier's job to lose at this point?

It's YOU, not ME who's pretending to have some insider access to what coaches are "really" thinking. You make it so obvious with your final statement, "Let those who know the game and this team share words of wisdom while you just react."

That's awful rich coming from a guy so football illiterate that he just lost an argument over the difference between a post route and a corner route by not understanding that a post route is called such because it's run to the post, and a corner because it's run to the corner.

I've about had my fill of the "wisdom" you seem to be far too over eager to share.
 
Advertisement
ThomasM said:
One play in practice means he can run the O, go through progressions, hit guys in stride, and generally make good decisions with the ball in his hands. If juke moves is all it takes to play QB, why the heck didn't we play Devin Hester at QB?
Click to expand...

If you think that play is meant to show anything about throwing ability then you're following the wrong sport.
 
Loose Cannon said:
Why would I want a QB who can escape a perfectly clean pocket. He stepped up and let the ends go by, just like you're taught to do. Then he just ran for no apparent reason out of a clean pocket right into the defender who had QB responsibility on the play. Leaving a clean pocket without ever looking downfield isn't escapability. It's stupidity. If he meets any P5 1st string linebacker he gets leveled. As it were, he met Derrion Owens who transferred to G5 Houston because he lost his 2nd string spot.
Click to expand...

Lmao, clean pocket? He was about to get sacked.
**** you're lost.
 
Who cares is Perry, Weldon, Jarren, or even Rosier can take it 60 yards or if he'd get caught at 50. Why does that matter?
 
Milkcane said:
Lmao, clean pocket? He was about to get sacked.
**** you're lost.
Click to expand...
Take a look at the still. Don't click play. Observe the scene first. The tackles have done their job and pushed the ends too far up field to be a factor. There are 4 orange jerseys in front of the QB and only 1 white jersey. That lone white jersey is not attacking. He's holding QB contain. All Perry needs to do is take a single step forward to be completely out of harms way and have plenty of time to scan the field. Instead Perry runs right towards the one guy he should not. That Darrion Owens failed to make the play has more to do with him being demoted from 2nd string to 3rd, than Perry being promoted from clipboard co signal caller. Pocket awareness my ***. That play is a demonstration of what NOT to do. That play is an example of a guy who doesn't know what to do and falls back to the only thing he can do. Run.
 
ThomasM said:
I'm saying that if one play in practice excites you, you're a fool.
Click to expand...

That one play was definitely exciting, but if you're trying to draw conclusions about his overall game when it was clearly posted to show how dynamic and elusive he can be then you're the **** fool, an ignorant one at that.
 
Last edited:
Loose Cannon said:
2 things:

1. Darrion Owens was not good enough to play here. He managed 41 tackles in 4 years and transferred back to G5 Houston to be with Dorito.
2. Owens had contain on that play. Perry stepped up into a clean pocket and instead of looking down field decided to run INTO the contain man.

You see elite quickness. I see a ****-poor decision meeting a LB who transferred because he was about to lose his spot on 2nd string. Had Perry met actual elite talent on that play, say an LB like Roquan Smith, Howard Landry, or Tremaine Edmunds, we could have just put a head stone in that spot because Perry would have been killed.
Click to expand...
Yeah, if Perry does this vs fsboo or any other hested rivalry game he will in all likelihood be entering the concussion protocol shortly after. But nonetheless sweet practoce moves.
 
Advertisement
Wash140in60 said:
Yeah, if Perry does this vs fsboo or any other hested rivalry game he will in all likelihood be entering the concussion protocol shortly after. But nonetheless sweet practoce moves.
Click to expand...

Same thing happens if he stands there. lol at those saying that was a clean pocket. He has a split decision to choose what to do there and no time to scan the field aside from the primary receiver he was on at the moment. That guy isn't open, you do what he did and make a play

I have no idea if anyone was open and its funny how people have opinions without even a clear picture to look at. What is available in those three seconds, he made the correct call.
 
Perry's raw arm talent enamors me more than those practice moves. It could take a while for that to translate to Saturdays though.
 
Back
Top