forums

Richt on the qb order

If we are starting Malik next year thats on Richt; and all the people who excused his putrid offense bc of “he doesnt have his QB” will be silent.
 
Advertisement
Loose Cannon said:
Now I'm confused. Is your beef because we have Nkosi Perry at QB instead of Lamar Jackson, or that we have Mark Richt as HC instead of Bobby Patrino?

"From the staff/players, it seems that this years version Perry is capable of winning 10-12(considering the schedule)and a better result in the acccg"

So 10 wins is not guaranteed with a guy who's done it, yet 10-12 is with a guy who's never taken a snap? And just stop it with the "he doesn't have any experience because CMR wouldn't play him," bull****. The guy who in your mind doesn't deserve another snap beat out and is still ahead of the guy you think should be starting because he's earned it. If and when Nkosi EARNS the job he'll get his chance, but it will not be because you or any other porsters here don't think Rosier deserves another snap.
Click to expand...

LOL, haven't you been paying attention? Perry is much better than Rosier, always has been. The only possible explanation is that Richt is afraid to play him. I mean, did you even look at that clip? The guy can not get sacked and juke people and stuff. If he's a better runner than Rosier, so there's no possible reason not to play him.
 
Loose Cannon said:
Why would I want a QB who can escape a perfectly clean pocket. He stepped up and let the ends go by, just like you're taught to do. Then he just ran for no apparent reason out of a clean pocket right into the defender who had QB responsibility on the play. Leaving a clean pocket without ever looking downfield isn't escapability. It's stupidity. If he meets any P5 1st string linebacker he gets leveled. As it were, he met Derrion Owens who transferred to G5 Houston because he lost his 2nd string spot.
Click to expand...

Christ.
 
kryptonite said:
LOL, haven't you been paying attention? Perry is much better than Rosier, always has been. The only possible explanation is that Richt is afraid to play him. I mean, did you even look at that clip? The guy can not get sacked and juke people and stuff. If he's a better runner than Rosier, so there's no possible reason not to play him.
Click to expand...

I’m pulling for Perry, but it’s premature to say he’s “better” than anybody. Pretty much anyone will agree has much better overall passing skills, a better arm, and overall he’s a better physical specimen as far as a passer. Taller, can see the field better from a physical perspective.

It will be great if he can put it all together and I’m praying he does.

But.....just because he’s better in shorts, in shells, and throws better in practices, doesn’t mean that translates to the film room, the mental and decision making aspects of the game, the scrimmages, and in actual college games.

Rick isn’t afraid to play him. Rick wants to play the guy that gives him the best chance to get the W. Perry has yet to prove he can do a better job as the QB. It’s as simple as that. He hasn’t had the chance this year yet. He will soon.

He has several scrimmages to step up and take the job. That’s what he needs to do. Whoever is the better leader and wins the scrimmages, based on the criteria Rick has set, is the starter. It’s that simple.
 
Last edited:
Perry is extremely athletic but what deeply concerns me is his mental game. Rosier is sharp as a tack— yes he throws picks but it has more to do with his accuracy (which don’t get me wrong is an issue) than misreads. There’s mumblings that Perry still can’t read defenses. That’s a problem. I’ve heard that Perry half-asses in class too by sleeping through lectures and that only adds fuel to my concern. IF this is true— it may or may not be— than I would apologetically root for Rosier to start and Williams to start next year.
 
OriginalCanesCanesCanes said:
I’m pulling for Perry, but it’s premature to say he’s “better” than anybody. Pretty much anyone will agree has much better overall passing skills, a better arm, and overall he’s a better physical specimen as far as a passer. Taller, can see the field better from a physical perspective.

It will be great if he can put it all together and I’m praying he does.

But.....just because he’s better in shorts, in shells, and throws better in practices, doesn’t mean that translates to the film room, the mental and decision making aspects of the game, the scrimmages, and in actual college games.

Rick isn’t afraid to play him. Rick wants to play the guy that gives him the best chance to get the W. Perry has yet to prove he can do a better job as the QB. It’s as simple as that. He hasn’t had the chance this year yet. He will soon.

He has several scrimmages to step up and take the job. That’s what he needs to do. Whoever is the better leader and wins the scrimmages, based on the criteria Rick has set, is the starter. It’s that simple.
Click to expand...

That's it. People always assume there's some better QB sitting on the bench. Hopefully that's true right now and that guy gets it together and wins the job, but it's silly to think Richt isn't playing him because he's scared or has some personal feelings on the matter. Richt wants to win and as soon as Perry is the best chance we have at winning, he'll see the field.
 
EL U said:
Perry is extremely athletic but what deeply concerns me is his mental game. Rosier is sharp as a tack— yes he throws picks but it has more to do with his accuracy (which don’t get me wrong is an issue) than misreads. There’s mumblings that Perry still can’t read defenses. That’s a problem. I’ve heard that Perry half-asses in class too by sleeping through lectures and that only adds fuel to my concern. IF this is true— it may or may not be— than I would apologetically root for Rosier to start and Williams to start next year.
Click to expand...

I’m guessing you’re a student.

Don’t know if you’re familiar with a football player’s workload, especially at a place like Miami, unlike Alabama, where at least an attempt is made to get these young men a semblance of an education, but I would not be overly concerned about this idle gossip about him catching twenty winks, even if it’s true.

Why don’t you try being a college quarterback, going to QB film room, going to QB study room, learn plays, go to 3-4 hour practices every day and maybe squeeze in a little social life, and oh yeah, go to class, too. A little shuteye in class? Who cares.

I used to sometimes nod off in classes at UM too. Usually because I was hungover.

Silly stuff like this is irrelevant. If he’s having trouble picking up the playbook it has nothing to do with whether he’s sleepy in class. Jesus, you people....
 
OriginalCanesCanesCanes said:
He’s got another 4-5 months. Hoping he makes the most of it.
Click to expand...
He easily could. We know so little of what he is actually capable of regarding the mental status of the position. Obviously he has all the physical tools, but watching his tape whoch is all I have as a fan, all he did was out athlete teams. Which is spectacular, but not necessarily a prerequisite for elite d1 qb sucess. I am LONG on him because if he doesn't have that know there is nothing to say he wouldn't destroy the ncaa as a 21 22 year old bu the time he learns.
 
Advertisement
Wash140in60 said:
He easily could. We know so little of what he is actually capable of regarding the mental status of the position. Obviously he has all the physical tools, but watching his tape whoch is all I have as a fan, all he did was out athlete teams. Which is spectacular, but not necessarily a prerequisite for elite d1 qb sucess. I am LONG on him because if he doesn't have that know there is nothing to say he wouldn't destroy the ncaa as a 21 22 year old bu the time he learns.
Click to expand...

Oh, he definitely could. But not easily. I’m hoping he does. It would not be easy for anybody.
 
Back
Top