Ranking Our Commits

[Hurricane Warning]

This is honestly a springboard for conversation because I know there are others on this board that know much more than I do, but from what I've seen:

1. Don Chaney
2. Tyler Van Dyke
3. Michael Redding
4. Jaiden Francois
5. Marcus Fleming
6. Jalen Rivers
7. Elijah Roberts
8. Daran Branch
9. Dominic Mammereli
10. Willie Moise
11. Quentin Williams
12. Corey Flagg
13. Xavier Restrepo
14. Alvin Mathis
15. Antonio Smith
16. Keshawn Washington
17. Chris Washington
18. Tre'Von Riggins
19. Justin Hodges

Again, would love to hear others thoughts... even if it's that I'm a dumbass that shouldn't ever attempt to evaluate again lol.

 

[mirvin88]

Nailed it, IMO

 

[305to954]

Imo I’d put van dyke at 1 just because of the position and by all accounts he is that *****

 

[Captain Uberpants]

I’d have Rivers at 3 because he’s actually a 4 star tackle, biggest need of the class.

 

[mirvin88]

I’d have Rivers at 3 because he’s actually a 4 star tackle, biggest need of the class.

If you're ranking based on importance I'd shake it up. But purely on individual potential I agree with the OP.

 

[A1cane]

This is honestly a springboard for conversation because I know there are others on this board that know much more than I do, but from what I've seen:

1. Don Chaney
2. Tyler Van Dyke
3. Michael Redding
4. Jaiden Francois
5. Marcus Fleming
6. Jalen Rivers
7. Elijah Roberts
8. Daran Branch
9. Dominic Mammereli
10. Willie Moise
11. Quentin Williams
12. Corey Flagg
13. Xavier Restrepo
14. Alvin Mathis
15. Antonio Smith
16. Keshawn Washington
17. Chris Washington
18. Tre'Von Riggins
19. Justin Hodges

Again, would love to hear others thoughts... even if it's that I'm a dumbass that shouldn't ever attempt to evaluate again lol.

If the ranking is about importance to our team I would put rivers 1 and Cheney 2

 

[BoxingRobes]

You underrate Xavier Restrepo quite a bit.

 

[Mikep]

You're a dumb *** that shouldn't ever attempt to evaluate again. lol

But seriously, I have no idea.

 

[HighSeas]

Good idea but it's too soon for this imo. I'll post mine much later in the process.

Only certainty is Van Dyke will be my #1 guy.

 

[yeaman]

Why do you have Rivers so low.. I'm curious. The more I watch him I think hes underrated.

 

[brock]

Good idea but it's too soon for this imo. I'll post mine much later in the process.

Only certainty is Van Dyke will be my #1 guy.

Still got Chaney #1 for me, he’s a premium legit 5 star talent.

#1 Chaney
#2 rivers
#3 Francois
#4 Redding
#5 Fleming
#6 Elijah Roberts
#7 van dyke
#8 willie moise
#9 Quentin Williams
#10 Xavier restrepo

My top 10 so far.

 

[Hurricane Warning]

Why do you have Rivers so low.. I'm curious. The more I watch him I think hes underrated.

Nothing against him, I just think the guys above him are that good. Chaney and TVD were the clear top 2, but after that it got tough. Razor thin margins between 3-9.

 

[Hurricane Warning]

You underrate Xavier Restrepo quite a bit.

Perhaps. He's impressive in camps and a hard worker. Can't wait to see more in pads. Definitely a strong candidate to move up many spots whenever I revisit.

 

[Hurricane Warning]

Good idea but it's too soon for this imo. I'll post mine much later in the process.

Only certainty is Van Dyke will be my #1 guy.

Ur probably right, just dog day chatter lol.

 

[NaplesCane]

Francois will be the best of the whole bunch. He will be starting by next year.

 

[Hurricane Warning]

If the ranking is about importance to our team I would put rivers 1 and Cheney 2

I'd put TVD at 1, but yeah those 2 right after.

 

[brcane1]

Francois above the WRs.

 

[grover]

Call me old school. But I don't like doing ratings in a public forum. The recruits and their friends and family read these boards.

 

[theibisrules]

Mathis will be climbing everbodies list...book it!!!

 

[mirvin88]

Call me old school. But I don't like doing ratings in a public forum. The recruits and their friends and family read these boards.

May as well just shut the site down if we aren't going to discuss players or recruits