Ranking Miami QB's over the last Decade

[Mark Little]

And it was the 15 year anniversary of the 2001 team.

Oh no!

No!

Not that!

 

[Mark Little]

I’m a kaaya fan but I doubt seehow anyone could argue against it

Because I'm not an idiot like you and I have the facts.

 

[PGrady24]

Why do you feel the need to insult everyone (idiot, buffoon, loon,etc.) instead of just soundly providing your "facts"? Are you that insecure on the inside? Just curious

 

[Loose Cannon]

Blaming Golden, defenses, inflation, the boogeyman, whatever...cannot change the fact that Kaaya had multiple opportunities to make a game winning play, but never did.

 

[Mark Little]

Why do you feel the need to insult everyone (idiot, buffoon, loon,etc.) instead of just soundly providing your "facts"? Are you that insecure on the inside? Just curious

Because you're still fighting it.

At this point it must be stupidity.

 

[Mark Little]

In other words, Dorsey at 57% completion was above the median in 2001. Rosier at 54% completion was FAR below the median.

Not remotely comparable.

And to add to this, a median QB in 2001 finished with 15 TDs in an 11 game season. The median QB in 2017 finished with 21 TDs in a 13 game season.

So, again, Dorsey far superior to Rosier (as if that needed to be said).

 

[Mark Little]

Blaming Golden, defenses, inflation, the boogeyman, whatever...cannot change the fact that Kaaya had multiple opportunities to make a game winning play, but never did.

This is not an ability even though you are desperately trying to claim that it is.

 

[Loose Cannon]

Because you're still fighting it.

At this point it must be stupidity.

Not at all due to the fact that Kaaya never engineered a game winning drive.

 

[Loose Cannon]

And to add to this, a median QB in 2001 finished with 15 TDs in an 11 game season. The median QB in 2017 finished with 21 TDs in a 13 game season.

So, again, Dorsey far superior to Rosier (as if that needed to be said).

How many Hurricanes have finished a season with more than 3588 yards and 31 TDs?

 

[Loose Cannon]

This is not an ability even though you are desperately trying to claim that it is.

lol...completing a pass or otherwise making the game winning play is not an ability?

 

[Mark Little]

Not at all due to the fact that Kaaya never engineered a game winning drive.

I don't think a win is less significant if a QB leads this team to, say, a big early lead then it is to come from behind.

You're just using this fake metric because you have nothing else to defend Rosier with.

 

[Loose Cannon]

The median QB in 2017 finished with 21 TDs in a 13 game season.

So, median? That's like average, right? 21 TDs in 13 games is average...what is 10 more than that?

 

[Mark Little]

How many Hurricanes have finished a season with more than 3588 yards and 31 TDs?

So you're saying that Kaaya is the greatest quarterback in school history because nobody has thrown for more yards?

 

[Loose Cannon]

I don't think a win is less significant if a QB leads this team to, say, a big early lead then it is to come from behind.

You're just using this fake metric because you have nothing else to defend Rosier with.

Were not talking about wins vs wins. We're talking about wins vs losses. When did they start handing out trophies after 3 quarters? What QB award has ever been won in the 3rd quarter?

 

[canesproponent]

Kaaya was a MUCH BETTER quarterback than Rosier.

Am dumbfounded that people are even trying to argue this. Also, a QB that is 2 basis points above the median and one that 5 basis points below the median are markedly different on a statistically significant basis. There is zero dispute there......

 

[Mark Little]

That's like average, right?

No, it's median.

Go read a book.

 

[Mark Little]

So, median? That's like average, right? 21 TDs in 13 games is average...what is 10 more than that?

Rosier had 26 passing TDs. Less than 25% more than the median.

Dorsey had 23. More than 50% of the median.

 

[Mark Little]

Were not talking about wins vs wins. We're talking about wins vs losses.

No we're not.

Since a QB can win a game going away and avoid giving himself a chance to win late.

I don't think you've completely thought through this stuff.

 

[PGrady24]

Kaaya threw for 60% against Clemson in the 58-0 game. Stud

 

[Loose Cannon]

So you're saying that Kaaya is the greatest quarterback in school history because nobody has thrown for more yards?

No because he wasn't a winner. My metric is very consistent. It doesn't require hypothetical "if" scenarios. You had the ball and a chance to win the game. What happened?

Did all the rest of the team suck every single time Kaaya was put in that situation and lost? I understand you place no blame on him for being in that situation the same way you blame Rosier for the need to win games in the fourth...what did Kaaya do when he WAS in those positions?