Tate has far less arm talent than Jarren or Perry.
He can't throw the ball effectively in this Enos Offense because he doesn't have the arm to get the ball to the outside routes. He can run & scramble, but his lack of arm talent would suffer immensely having to play under center so much.
Defenses would sit on everything short, jumping every route, the most he could do is run for a few yards once the play breaks down. Enos would have to change the entire offense & scheme around Tate running a Read Option Offense & that's something he would never do.
The fact is, the best this offense will look is when we go 4-wide sets & SPREAD the field with a QB that can actually deliver with velocity & arm strength to all parts of the field. Perry is at his best when the coaches have no choice but to let him just go out there & throw indiscriminately, when you bog him down by trying to make him into this ultra conservative Captain Checkdown type QB he'll play terrible.
This is why some of us (me! Lol) keep screaming to the high heavens that we need to completely convert to a Spread Offense. It's what best fits out personnel & gives us the best chance to win.
When we Spread the Defense out, go with tempo & just let it rip we can actually move the **** ball & put points on the board, playing that ultra conservative slow take every snap under center ball has us putting up 17-24 points & ultimately losing because the Defense can't hold up.
We should be playing much faster, running 70+ plays a game & throwing the ball A LOT more.