forums

Coaching Possibly an unpopular idea, but…

nystateofmind

nystateofmind

C'est la vie
Banned
Joined
Dec 30, 2012
Messages
16,298
How would you guys feel about Joe Judge coming in as AHC/ST coordinator once he’s let go by the Giants?

Coached at Bama right before Mario got there so they’re probably familiar with each other. Flamed out as HC but was the best ST coach in the NFL for almost five years. And as previously mentioned, he has college coaching experience.
 
Last edited:
Advertisement
why would that be unpopular other than we might ending up naming 4 cats AHC?

if the guy is a firstrate ST coach then we should move heaven and earth to get him here.
 
nystateofmind said:
How would you guys feel about Joe Judge coming in as AHC/ST coordinator once he’s let go by the Giants?

Coached at Bama right before Mario got there so I’m sure they’re familiar with each other. Flamed out as HC but was the best ST coach in the NFL for almost five years. And as previously mentioned, he has college coaching experience.
Click to expand...


Not sure how people type sentences like this without thinking or editing, but it happens...

Still, appreciated how you shoehorned "flamed" and "out" into the analysis...
 
nystateofmind said:
How would you guys feel about Joe Judge coming in as AHC/ST coordinator once he’s let go by the Giants?

Coached at Bama right before Mario got there so I’m sure they’re familiar with each other. Flamed out as HC but was the best ST coach in the NFL for almost five years. And as previously mentioned, he has college coaching experience.
Click to expand...

He's a special teams expert. Being a HC in the NFL is hard. If you're the worst one there you're still the 32nd best person in the world at your job in theory. People need to keep in mind just how well regarded you have to be just to get a shot. This would be a Saban move. I'd pick him up at the airport myself. Bring him to me.
 
Advertisement
nystateofmind said:
How would you guys feel about Joe Judge coming in as AHC/ST coordinator once he’s let go by the Giants?

Coached at Bama right before Mario got there so I’m sure they’re familiar with each other. Flamed out as HC but was the best ST coach in the NFL for almost five years. And as previously mentioned, he has college coaching experience.
Click to expand...
He is going back to Saban or Belichick, so forget that.
 
TheOriginalCane said:
Not sure how people type sentences like this without thinking or editing, but it happens...

Still, appreciated how you shoehorned "flamed" and "out" into the analysis...
Click to expand...
I’m not sure what you mean, friend.

Cristobal got to Bama in 2013 and Judge left in 2012. Judge also accompanied Belichick various times to Bama pro days so I’m sure they’ve interacted.

Anyway, I hope you’re having a great day.

:)
 
Advertisement
I can't see how anyone would have a problem with this. Especially if we could time it so he's still here when Devin Hester's son comes along.
 
At what salary? I know Mario has a large budget for staff, but not bottomless. What would you have to pay a newly-fired NFL HC to coach a college program's special teams? Also, isn't ST coordinator often a position coaches 'other job'? What else is Judge's experience?

That said, I'd be all in for getting one of the best coaches in every spot...
 
Advertisement
TemplarCane said:
At what salary? I know Mario has a large budget for staff, but not bottomless. What would you have to pay a newly-fired NFL HC to coach a college program's special teams. Also, isn't ST coordinator often a position coaches 'other job'? What else is Judge's experience?

That said, I'd be all in for getting one of the best coaches in every spot...
Click to expand...
Judge coached WR with the Patriots for one year in 2018, but I think McClendon is getting that spot. Although I suppose you could stick Judge with TE if we don’t land Partridge or Brewster.
 
nystateofmind said:
I’m not sure what you mean, friend.

Cristobal got to Bama in 2013 and Judge left in 2012. Judge also accompanied Belichick various times to Bama pro days so I’m sure they’ve interacted.

Anyway, I hope you’re having a great day.

:)
Click to expand...


So you started out claiming that you were SURE that Cristobal and Judge were familiar with each other due to non-overlapping tenures at a particular school, then you tried to rehab your BS by pivoting to "Judge probably interacted with Cristobal at Alabama Pro Days"?

Yeah, just drop the desperate nonsense. By your standards, Randy Shannon and Al Golden were butt buddies. Ridiculous.

Stick to afternoon BJs...
 
TheOriginalCane said:
So you started out claiming that you were SURE that Cristobal and Judge were familiar with each other due to non-overlapping tenures at a particular school, then you tried to rehab your BS by pivoting to "Judge probably interacted with Cristobal at Alabama Pro Days"?

Yeah, just drop the desperate nonsense. By your standards, Randy Shannon and Al Golden were butt buddies. Ridiculous.

Stick to afternoon BJs...
Click to expand...
Friend, it seems you have a lot of pent up anger. I hope this helps.

:)

 
Advertisement
nystateofmind said:
Judge coached WR with the Patriots for one year in 2018, but I think McClendon is getting that spot. Although I suppose you could stick Judge with TE if we don’t land Partridge or Brewster.
Click to expand...
Fair enough. I think Field was still 'penciled' in as TE coach with his recruiting abilities and past association with Mario at Oregon.

Hey, not a bad call, if Judge wants to/can recruit...
 
nystateofmind said:
How would you guys feel about Joe Judge coming in as AHC/ST coordinator once he’s let go by the Giants?

Coached at Bama right before Mario got there so I’m sure they’re familiar with each other. Flamed out as HC but was the best ST coach in the NFL for almost five years. And as previously mentioned, he has college coaching experience.
Click to expand...
My guess is he'll end up back with Belichick
 
TemplarCane said:
Fair enough. I think Field was still 'penciled' in as TE coach with his recruiting abilities and past association with Mario at Oregon.

Hey, not a bad call, if Judge wants to/can recruit...
Click to expand...
I like Field, but if Mario didn’t think highly enough of him to put him on staff as an assistant at Oregon, it’s fair to wonder if he’d do it here.

I could see him sliding back into the Director of Recruiting role while keeping the same salary he was pulling in as TE coach.
 
nystateofmind said:
How would you guys feel about Joe Judge coming in as AHC/ST coordinator once he’s let go by the Giants?

Coached at Bama right before Mario got there so they’re probably familiar with each other. Flamed out as HC but was the best ST coach in the NFL for almost five years. And as previously mentioned, he has college coaching experience.
Click to expand...
He'll be back with the Pats, licking his wounds, as do do most former Belichick disciples when they realize they aren't Belichick.
 
Advertisement
Back
Top