Overrated and underrated CFB coaches

[Plou]

I find Dan Mullen, Gary Patterson, Matt Campbell and Mike Gundy to be underrated.

By far #1 on my overrated list is Ed Orgeron. I think he’s a terrible coach who is only doing well because of his assistant’s salaries.

Scott Frost is #2 on my overrated list.

Other overrated coaches include Brian Kelly, Tom Herman, James Franklin and Mike Leach.

Dino Babers and Bronco Mendenhall used to be overrated, although I hope that nobody respects them now.

 

[HumbleCane]

troll

 

[Wildnation]

Jim Harbaugh

 

[Plou]

Jim Harbaugh

Does anybody seriously rate him highly anymore?

 

[Wildnation]

Does anybody seriously rate him highly anymore?

Hope not

 

[simplycanes]

I think most people hold Patterson and Gundy in high regard.

Brian Kelly is a joke. Arrogant as all **** for a guy the loses pretty much every big game in spectacular fashion.

 

[TexasCane90]

Campbell at Iowa St i think is underrated still...

He is doing so much at a perineal loser competing and beating the big boys in Texas and Oklahoma yearly now

 

[Plou]

Campbell at Iowa St i think is underrated still...

He is doing so much at a perineal loser competing and beating the big boys in Texas and Oklahoma yearly now

Didn’t think of him. I’ll add him to my underrated list.

 

[BS85]

David Shaw- overrated
Chris Peterson- down year but still underrated

 

[305407cane]

Franklin is overrated

 

[Plou]

I think Manny Diaz is currently an overrated coach, at least on CIS.

 

[Kempo Cane]

I think Manny Diaz is currently an overrated coach, at least on CIS.

OP

 

[Angry Ibis]

I think Manny Diaz is currently an overrated coach, at least on CIS.

Troll not getting the attention double down move.....

How are some of your choices underrated?

Mullen coaching at a Power 5 SEC school???

 

[Eric The Midget]

There's a total of 5 coaches in cfb who've won a ring. You could say most are overrated.

 

[ben]

A lot of CISers overrate ACC coaches like Babers and Bronco

 

[Cribby]

Cis logic “everyone is overrated”.....unless you won a natty.

 

[QuattroCane]

A lot of CISers overrate ACC coaches like Babers and Bronco

I still think Bronco is legit. He has UVA competitive much fast than anyone thought would be the case.

 

[Memnon]

David Shaw- overrated
Chris Peterson- down year but still underrated

In what world is David Shaw overrated???

86-31 for his career, 3 Pac-12 titles, 5 North Division titles, 5 Bowl wins, all while having the most difficulty in recruiting due to the stringent academic requirements of Stanford. You do realize that Stanford gives out the least amount of athletic scholarships in Football per year than any other program in the nation right?

The man hasn't had single losing season in his entire career as a HC until this year while literally having 4 starting Offensive linemen out for the season, 2 starting LB's, their Punter & both their QB's being injured throughout most of the season.

 

[Plou]

I still think Bronco is legit. He has UVA competitive much fast than anyone thought would be the case.

He’s been an upgrade over Mike London, which isn’t saying a lot. I think Mendenhall is a corch, as is Babers.

 

[Heart of The Playmaker]

I think Manny Diaz is currently an overrated coach, at least on CIS.

Troll alert