Interesting you mention Scandanavian countries. Their cradle to grave welfare programs render marriages obsolete. You are correct. Couples "marry" and have kids but have no obligation to maintain the relationship. However, essentially individuals become wedded to the state. Personally I would rather promote the integrity of the family as a bottom up foundation to society vs some top down state leviathan that I will be dependent upon the rest of my life.
You’re bringing ideology into the mix, which weakens your stance. Namely, it seems you’re veering towards the American construct of marriage as an ideal. For example, and to paraphrase your original point, you stated “getting married to bear children were foundational to building a strong society”. So, as a counterpoint, I mentioned Scandinavia to disprove that premise, especially since the US is only 4.7% of the worlds population. That’s just a slither.
I’m focusing mostly on western societies (plural) - Europe, UK, Canada, Australia, US, because our systems are relatively similar, but the takeaway is, there are many different kinds of societies built on wholly different principles and institutions. But I certainly can’t wrap my brain around marriage and having children as some duty to the State for building society. That seems far closer to being wedded to the state under that concept, than a single patent being so called wedded to the state in scandanavia.
Also, not only do I disagree social programs have rendered marriages obsolete in scandanavia, I totally disagree Scandavia is a cradle to the grave welfare society (they practice compassionate capitalism), and I’ll argue against both premises with these points:
1. Their cultural norms are just different (see cultural relativism)...America is a very young country and still figuring things out, I’d argue and,
2. Denmark is ranked nearly 10 spots HIGHER than the US on the Index of Economics freedom scale....and Sweden is only a few spots behind the US. The index of Economic Freedom is an annual index created by the Wall Street Journal and Heritage Foundation to measure the degree of economic freedom in the worlds nations. It’s underpinned by Adam Smiths approach in the Wealth of nations. Denmark is 8, US is 17 and Sweden is ranked 22
Also, America is the second largest social welfare state in the world and it’s most certainly cradle to the grave, which nullifies your point about welfare programs making marriages in Scandinavia obsolete. Their society is strong and there are having children out of wedlock choosing not to marry as a choice. Real per capita social welfare spending in the United States is second largest in the world. America is the epitome of a so called welfare state!
Since our founding in 1973, The Heritage Foundation has been working to advance the principles of free enterprise, limited government, individual freedom, traditional American values, and a strong national defense.
www.heritage.org
Since our founding in 1973, The Heritage Foundation has been working to advance the principles of free enterprise, limited government, individual freedom, traditional American values, and a strong national defense.
www.heritage.org