forums

On Emmanuel Karnley...

DC3 said:
So you think Beck is going to be a 1st rounder this year or just mad because I said Nix had better arm talent?
Click to expand...
I hope Beck is a 1st rounder b/c that is good news for my team ... the Miami Hurricanes.

You made an ill informed claim of Nix/Penix having strong arms and I simply pointed out you were wrong on Nix.
 
Advertisement
ssvir said:
I hope Beck is a 1st rounder b/c that is good news for my team ... the Miami Hurricanes.

You made an ill informed claim of Nix/Penix having strong arms and I simply pointed out you were wrong on Nix.
Click to expand...

I think both do have stronger arms than Beck does.

I don’t think he’s a 1st round talent but he is still be good enough to compete for an ACC title provided the inexperienced skill players can mesh with him after only 3/4 months of throwing with him.
 
DC3 said:
The other 2 also have better Arm talent than Beck did when healthy.

I can show you Brad Kayaa’s odds of being QB1 coming into his money year or other former highly ranked offseason QBs that fell.

Beck is going to be a solid QB for Miami, but I don’t think he’s a day 1 guy.
Click to expand...
Kaaya was never on Carson Beck level 🤣🤣🤣

Carson Beck has the talent to be a 1st round pick, and if he’s not then he didn’t have a good year this year
 
mods I apologize for derailing this thread and not giving this Canes legend the attention he deserves
 
CANESCANES said:
Kaaya was never on Carson Beck level 🤣🤣🤣

Carson Beck has the talent to be a 1st round pick, and if he’s not then he didn’t have a good year this year
Click to expand...
I liked Brad but yea, come on, let's not be silly. Beck has a much stronger arm and is a much better athlete than Brad ever was. And Brad's mechanics were always shaky.
 
CANESCANES said:
Kaaya was never on Carson Beck level 🤣🤣🤣

Carson Beck has the talent to be a 1st round pick, and if he’s not then he didn’t have a good year this year
Click to expand...

I used him as an example of how preseason 1st round expectations don’t mean a thing
 
Advertisement
DC3 said:
I used him as an example of how preseason 1st round expectations don’t mean a thing
Click to expand...
They are certainly more meaningful for a QB with 2 years of experience than 1, and for a QB going into year 6 than year 2.
Can still be very wrong, like Ewers this year. But also you can argue Ewers could have worked himself into the first of the stars aligned... Whereas Kaaya couldn't have entering year 4...
 
Back
Top