forums

NFL Hall of Fame finalists

FuriousStyles said:
NBA is definitely worse… very good players get statutes these days
Click to expand...
Excuse me, but MLB would like to have a word with both of you....

1770417352350.png
 
Advertisement
When Phil Rizzuto got into Cooperstown, but not Omar Vizquel, the co-greatest SS of all time, as well as having better offensive stats in many categories than Ozzie, it showed what a crock of **** MLB Hall is.

The knock on Reggie is he played on a great offense. But the flip side is he also had to split touches with Marvin Harrison and Edge, so why isn’t that a knock on Craig? Montana and Jerry Rice?

If the argument is that someone had a great SB, then why isn’t Plunkett or OJ Anderson in?

The only eligible WR above Wayne in career receptions is Boldin, while Reed, Monk, Bruce and Moss are in but well below Wayne.
 
RF-4CCane said:
When Phil Rizzuto got into Cooperstown, but not Omar Vizquel, the co-greatest SS of all time, as well as having better offensive stats in many categories than Ozzie, it showed what a crock of **** MLB Hall is.

The knock on Reggie is he played on a great offense. But the flip side is he also had to split touches with Marvin Harrison and Edge, so why isn’t that a knock on Craig? Montana and Jerry Rice?

If the argument is that someone had a great SB, then why isn’t Plunkett or OJ Anderson in?

The only eligible WR above Wayne in career receptions is Boldin, while Reed, Monk, Bruce and Moss are in but well below Wayne.
Click to expand...
Great points but as to Roger Craig, they clearly held it against him because he retired 32 years ago. Keeping whatever they held against him for how long they did is nonsense however you slice it. Anybody who watched him play in the era he played in knows he was HOF worthy. But if they don’t agree then stand on that… if he is HOF worthy in 2026 then he was HOF worthy since ‘99 (post first ballot eligible).

If they make Reggie wait 30+ years they are FOS. The Hall has shown its hand already. Needs overhauling.
 
FuriousStyles said:
NBA is definitely worse… very good players get statutes these days
Click to expand...
NBA is a joke now because every decent player is treated like a superstar. NFL really slipping the last several seasons. At least the NBA and NFL will always get it right with legit superstars. The top dogs will always be in.

Can't say that about MLB. Bonds, Clemens, Pete Rose, A-Rod, and some others should be in. I don't care if they did PED's. A lot of players were also doing them. Fat slob David Ortiz took PED's and also Albert Pujols. They were still both amazing hitters (Pujols could also play the field) and deserve to be in Cooperstown. Baseball voters and writers loved those 2 guys. They don't like Bonds and Clemens, because they were mean to them. Give me a break. Baseball writers are a bunch of pussies and can go **** themselves.
 
Back
Top