• Attention: Register today to view CanesInSight Ad-Free for 7 days.

Off-Topic New York Pizza

Ethnicsands

All-American
Joined
Nov 2, 2011
Messages
22,060
Bleecker's didn't strike me as a trendy, hipster establishment. I lived in Brooklyn during early 70s as a kid, before it was trendy, and this pizza was reminiscent of that era.
Having said this, I will try Sal&Carmine next time I'm in town.
as long as you like a traditional nyc ‘slice,’ it’s really good.
 

redrum234

Recruit
Joined
Jan 3, 2017
Messages
349
You can't be all bad because you appreciate that Sally's > Pepe's. Modern is okay. Teh world just didn't need more than 2 'new haven pizza' places. And it generally doesn't need more than 1 place that sells 'apizza.'

In any case, these pie purveyors have been living on association with poverty and leftist idiocy at Yale for generations. I do believe they were legit places back when the mob ran the port, but those days ended about with jimmy hoffa and the advent of Wal-Mart.

Most folks here won't even understand this history.
My friend, my take is only on taste. History be damned. I could care less. Taste is king.
 
Joined
Mar 15, 2013
Messages
6,938
If you can find a local real wood fired oven pizza with thin crust save yourself some time and money. I love NYC and have eaten many slices from legendary pizza joints, but some shitz is highly over blown.
 

ithacane

Original Grassy Gangster
Joined
Sep 8, 2017
Messages
684
I’ve had Grimaldi and Pepe from the convos on here... which were both decent. Anyone here checked out the pizza in the Scranton/old forge PA area? Some legit pizza like Revello’s and others I can’t remember. My fav is a place called Pizza Perfect in Trucksville.
 

Cajuncane

Senior
Joined
Apr 22, 2017
Messages
9,434
So @Cajuncane, which pizza(s) did you finally end up ordering from Goldbelly's that you would recommend.
I ended up getting them from Carlos’ Bakery and they we horrible.I wrote to Goldbelly and told them they were inedible and shouldn’t be allowed to sell their pizza...They gave me a credit toward my next purchase and I’m gonna re-order some from Di Falla which is supposed to be real good..
 

SpikeUM

Senior
Joined
Nov 3, 2011
Messages
5,515
I ended up getting them from Carlos’ Bakery and they we horrible.I wrote to Goldbelly and told them they were inedible and shouldn’t be allowed to sell their pizza...They gave me a credit toward my next purchase and I’m gonna re-order some from Di Falla which is supposed to be real good..

Thanks, lmk how Di Falla turns out. I am ordering a cake and bagels now from GB's.
 
Joined
Oct 2, 2017
Messages
1,359
I ended up getting them from Carlos’ Bakery and they we horrible.I wrote to Goldbelly and told them they were inedible and shouldn’t be allowed to sell their pizza...They gave me a credit toward my next purchase and I’m gonna re-order some from Di Falla which is supposed to be real good..

image.jpeg
image.jpeg
image.jpeg
 

Ethnicsands

All-American
Joined
Nov 2, 2011
Messages
22,060
So to break Pesach, which NY pizza do you recommend?
I’m not even sure I know anymore. Once you have kids pizza becomes a different food and different occasion. All the NY suggestions are okay but none are the mecca of pizza that some suggest, imo. There are different styles of pizza, obviously. I usually think of ‘NY pizza’ as a traditional ‘slice.’. If you want thin crust you’re looking for something else.
 
Top