I hate hyperbole and I’m not a ********* (though being a Miami fan would suggest otherwise)Sometimes a change of scenery does wonders. We've seen it a ton over time, and obviously way more recently with the portal.
This kid was awful last year, mostly on the outside. But you get him a new scheme, with a fresh start, at a more natural position, and play to his strengths, and he's one of the best DBs in the country.
Crazy how things can change from one year to the next. Literally NOBODY at Auburn batted an eye when he bounced. And he's been so **** good for us. IMO our 2nd or 3rd MVP on defense, just for how good he's been and how much I have no idea who'd play that spot were he not here.
I hate hyperbole and I’m not a ********* (though being a Miami fan would suggest otherwise)
But if we had him last year….
absolutely NOTHING would have changed... first, he likely would have played nickel, I give you that and Porter likely could have gone to his natural spot outside, but we still would have run way too many stunts and our safety play would still be god awful and it did not seem like we used our nickel last year the way heatherman does this year, blitzing, filling the B gap, closing on screens, etc. all this Scott does VERY well would have been gutted.I hate hyperbole and I’m not a ********* (though being a Miami fan would suggest otherwise)
But if we had him last year….
I want to believe better than last year, but not even close to this year.Guidry would've found a way to **** him up.
I almost tossed the grenade of grenades on this board a week or so ago, but I refrained. But I'll roll it under your desk.
If Lance Guidry was retained for 2025, and we had this exact roster (Bain at full health, Mesidor in the money year, the secondary talent infusion, Toure, etc)....is the defense as good as we have now? Close to as good? Not even close to as good? As bad as last year?
Obviously impossible to answer, but a fun question to really get everyone's blood pressure up.
It was a joking around comment with OBMabsolutely NOTHING would have changed... first, he likely would have played nickel, I give you that and Porter likely could have gone to his natural spot outside, but we still would have run way too many stunts and our safety play would still be god awful and it did not seem like we used our nickel last year the way heatherman does this year, blitzing, filling the B gap, closing on screens, etc. all this Scott does VERY well would have been gutted.
Recall the tape on him coming out of Auburn, and not to throw you under the bus but even your comment on the first page of his commitment thread you mentioned something like "taking a flyer on this guy to replace karnley and hope he returns to form? Ill take it i guess" is what most UM fans though about the pickup, no one could have envisioned him playing at this level and I think a lot of that has to do with what we are asking him to do. We definitely had a jimmy and joe problem on defense last year but the bigger issue IMO was the x and o's... we had Bain, Messidor, Barrow, Barron and lightfoot on the DL last year and the ones that returned look like new players this year.
Having him wouldn't have been enough to make antmy major difference.I hate hyperbole and I’m not a ********* (though being a Miami fan would suggest otherwise)
But if we had him last year….
I guess I should have put a bigger disclaimer on things.Having him wouldn't have been enough to make antmy major difference.
Didn't know much about him, thought he'd be depth. He's been a baller, playing his way into the NFLWho would have thunk it prior to the season that Scott would be the DB on the Thorpe list. Not OJ, Lucas, or Poyser.
Lance made the comment a few times and I’m not gonna steal it from him but Heatherman obviously knew what he wantedPleasant surprise; but when u got ppl to feed & a strong will, a light bulb can come on. Loved that he’s being recognized, & given flowers.
Well with the limited window it’s more of a middle dated one between the two. So there is more time than the original earlier window….Hope we can still make these types of evals in the new, limited portal window. I’m not sure what our defense would look like without Thomas and Scott, who both came in late window, correct?
I will never understand how EVERYONE saw the issues at DB from a mile away and the coaches who actually see practice, was like "Nah, we gucci".. Everytime I think about it, I smh..I hate hyperbole and I’m not a ********* (though being a Miami fan would suggest otherwise)
But if we had him last year….
(It was a ******* joke guys good lord)
Dude. Tons and tons of posts, evidence, and debates on this topic. Even then, as I spent all offseason harping on pure fear of our Safety situation, couldn’t have expected what we eventually saw. Never seen anything like that.I will never understand how EVERYONE saw the issues at DB from a mile away and the coaches who actually see practice, was like "Nah, we gucci".. Everytime I think about it, I smh..