Two things can be true.
The gator flat dominated that game, and Miami STILL should have won and if Thomas just catches a punt, they likely do. And IIRC, it was inside the 10 yard line, so he shouldn't have even been fielding it anyway.
But yes, the game wasn't Thomas's fault. That was just likely the final straw we couldn't overcome. They were a better overall team than we were at that point, and they tried literally as hard as they could to give us that game, but we wouldn't take it, and then Jeff forcefully gave it back.
God, what a ****** night. Two god awful teams. And then it took 18 hours to get out of the stadium.