Is Carson Beck officially a Canes legend?

[Mike Thot]

These guys are hitmen for hire now. No ship? No legend ever. Had weird eyes too.

 

[Handsome Squidbum]

You ordered a 7 course gourmet meal. First 6 plates were exquisite. Magnificently plated and the best food you have ever eaten. Compliments to the chef. Final plate was a **** on a garbage can lid.

So most of it was memorable and legendary, the ending was just extremely unfortunate and unpleasant.

 

[Hurricane23]

No

 

[Kempo Cane]

Legend Nah, but happy for the year we had.

 

[mirvin88]

No but he’s probably B tier

 

[klineski96]

Legend? Not quite... maybe this close...
But I'm a huge fan of his and will always root for him.

So grateful for what he did for Miami!
2025 was an AMAZING season!

 

[Dgixxer252525]

Na not a legend but a real Cane. I put him in the Kayaa category but just under Berlin.

Cam
Dorsey
Berlin
Beck
Kayaa
Rosier

I struffle to not put Cam #1 bc he had that crazy season and got drafted first overall

 

[Genghis Cane]

Na not a legend but a real Cane. I put him in the Kayaa category but just under Berlin.

Cam
Dorsey
Berlin
Beck
Kayaa
Rosier

I struffle to not put Cam #1 bc he had that crazy season and got drafted first overall

What’s your argument for having him below Berlin? Just curious.

 

[Kempo Cane]

Na not a legend but a real Cane. I put him in the Kayaa category but just under Berlin.

Cam
Dorsey
Berlin
Beck
Kayaa
Rosier

I struffle to not put Cam #1 bc he had that crazy season and got drafted first overall

Cam above Dorsey?

 

[plrwkyes]

not a legend, but on the high honor tier like a duke johnson or jaquan johnson

 

[CaneThang2020]

Yes….reflecting on his entire body of work for 2025 - this was absolutely a legendary season.

Cam Ward will be remembered, respected, and highly valued.

Carson Beck will be revered (dude beat 4 top 10 teams) and was 41 yards from beating 5.

The playoff era is a different era of college football and in this era, the 2025 team was legendary

 

[jtwist89]

We dont get Beck without Ward.. All those cool memories..

We may not even of got Tony without Ward. Ward put us back on the map.

 

[KingB02]

**** naaww! A better QB that can throw deep or over the shoulder passes and we win it all

 

[Kempo Cane]

My list of Cane all time Qbs
Walsh
Dorsey
Kelly
Erickson
Testeverde
Torreta
Cam
Beck
Berlin
Kaaya
Based on results and some just cause I liked them!

 

[QuattroCane]

Legend is a tough moniker at Miami, but when the switch flipped after SMU he played his butt off.
Had he made that last drive we’d be talking about where we were putting the statue.

 

[bshaw28]

I'm good if you think Beck is a Legend or just a great Cane player

But....The Ole Miss game winning TD run will be a legendary play

And in 1 season he beat:

Florida
FSU
#10 Notre Dame
#8 Texas A&M
#5 Ohio St
#3 Ole Miss

You're not going to get a better list than that

 

[Santana Sosa]

He can come to the BBQ with a plus 1 and get a plate. He has to share it with the plus 1 tho, so he might want to make good decisions.

Now, if he grows up and makes a 6'5 offspring with a rocket for an arm...terms can be renegotiated.

 

[aelmiami]

I never watched Vinny, Gino or Bernie. For those in my age and generation he’s T3. Hard to be s legend with only one year. You’d almost have to either do what Ward did or win the whole thing.

What I hope is, in ten years if we’ve won a title or two, we look back at Beck like we do Ward. Both took a chance on a program that was trending but not there. Beck didn’t quit when the weeds got high. Played the type of QB play we needed to get 40 yards from a title. Sucks neither Ward or Beck won a ring here. Both deserved it. But they are both instrumental in laying the foundation for this program imo.

I’d rated the QBs of my lifetime:

Dorsey
Ward
Beck
Berlin

Then just a group of Kaaya, Morris, Rosier and Harris.

 

[Kempo Cane]

My list of Cane all time Qbs
Walsh
Dorsey
Kelly
Erickson
Testeverde
Torreta
Cam
Beck
Berlin
Kaaya
Based on results and some just cause I liked them!

Lawd I forgot Kosar,insert him somewhere in that list.

 

[frostycane]

I can’t get to legend status. Very Brock Berlin to me. If he had more than one year here, then we’d be talking but given his tenure here, I just don’t see it.