forums

In your time of watching the Canes, is Rosier the worst starting qb at Miami you have ever seen?

Kirby Freeman for sure (just as bad at throwing but wished he one day could run like Rosier). Rosier is definitely second. I'd say Jacory Harris during the Mark Whipple years was face-to-palm inducing as well. I still have memories of seeing Harris look at his primary (who was wide open) and simply say to himself "**** it I'm going deep" and proceed to throw a half-hazard 40 yard duck to the opposing defense on 1st down.
 
Advertisement
Category 6 said:
Kirby Freeman for sure (just as bad at throwing but wished he one day could run like Rosier). Rosier is definitely second. I'd say Jacory Harris during the Mark Whipple years was face-to-palm inducing as well. I still have memories of seeing Harris look at his primary (who was wide open) and simply say to himself "**** it I'm going deep" and proceed to throw a half-hazard 40 yard duck to the opposing defense on 1st down.
Click to expand...

i blame whipple more than harris. whip's offense was predicated on that deep ball threat despite jacory having the touch without the strength. fisch made jacory look pretty decent for a year, minus the bc game.
 
I miss the days when we went from Kelly to Kosar to Testaverde to Walsh to Erickson to Torretta. Those were the days, who would have ever thought we'd struggle to find a quality QB.
 
Advertisement
No. Listen.

Kirby lost a game that Miami rushes for 300 yards and only allowed one touchdown on defense. He lost THAT game. Compare talent all you want. Malik has never had 300 yards from his backs and a defensive shutdown of only one TD and lost a game
 
If you didn’t travel 6 hours to sit in a miserably hot stadium and watch The WOrST football game ever played on that November day in 2007.... don’t even talk to me about who was worst. That was **** on earth.
 
KevinCaneFace said:
No. Listen.

Kirby lost a game that Miami rushes for 300 yards and only allowed one touchdown on defense. He lost THAT game. Compare talent all you want. Malik has never had 300 yards from his backs and a defensive shutdown of only one TD and lost a game
Click to expand...
IDK, ironically have you ever seen a qb look so bad and throw for 300 yards? Tells you talent we got and talent we play ain't the same.
 
MIA42178 said:
Kirby career 45%
Duhlik 46% last 6 games
Click to expand...

I remembered being confused as **** when I watched us barely beat Nevada because of that ****stick.

I was 8 years old asking my dad how we went from Ken Dorsey/Brock Berlin to this. All he said was “Old man Coker son...Old man Coker. I WANT BUTCH BACK!” (as he started to cry).
 
Advertisement
KevinCaneFace said:
If you didn’t travel 6 hours to sit in a miserably hot stadium and watch The WOrST football game ever played on that November day in 2007.... don’t even talk to me about who was worst. That was **** on earth.
Click to expand...
I traveled farther, and it might be the worst display ever. Not denying that.
 
Zbrod95 said:
I remembered being confused as **** when I watched us barely beat Nevada because of that ****stick.

I was 8 years old asking my dad how we went from Ken Dorsey/Brock Berlin to this. All he said was “Old man Coker son...Old man Coker. I WANT BUTCH BACK!” (as he started to cry).
Click to expand...
That was post championship. We thought Brock was the worst ever at the time. Our judgement was cloudy
 
Kirby Freeman
Kyle Wright
Robert Marve

Are the 3 worst in modern school history.
 
Keep this in mind, if the TD pass was properly reviewed, Freeman throws 2 TD passes in that game. He was 2 for 12, plus the TD pass yardage, with 3 picks. Feast or famine.
 
Back
Top