If Toney....

[fraggle]

Stats like he had yesterday when we play ND...give him the Heisman the race will be over.His only competion will be his QB.

 

[CIS_troll_killa]

Stats like he had yesterday when we play ND...give him the Heisman the race will be over.His only competion will be his QB.

I feel the same way, but everyone and their moms including ESPN is already crowning the dude from Ohio State.

 

[Jonnyblaze]

Stats like he had yesterday when we play ND...give him the Heisman the race will be over.His only competion will be his QB.

I like to believe that, but it’s Smith’s to lose.

 

[jtwist89]

Too bad they keep taking TDs away from him. Should have what, 3-4 more TDs if it wasnt for the refs.

 

[ben]

Malachi easily has the best highlight film of any player this season

 

[yeyo]

I feel the same way, but everyone and their moms including ESPN is already crowning the dude from Ohio State.

Sayin is out for the rest of the year so his production in Nov should take a dip

 

[Numb Nuts]

Sayin isnt great but hes good enough to get Smith the ball. But will the true freshman QB be able to? Smith doesn’t do punts, passes, or run the ball….so he’s pretty dependent upon a passer passing him the ball. Even if Sayin was healthy, there is always other ways Toney can impact games…things that Smith doesn’t do.

 

[Shooter McGavin]

Osu is screwed with their qb. Double Smith and that’s it.

 

[hurricaneman]

I agree, especially if that OSU offense struggles in any way.

Notre Dame will be Toneys chance to take it away.

 

[Colombie]

Malachi may have to break off some iconic punt return TDs to take the lead. Something I think he will do eventually.

Maybe do some Malicat TD runs and throws.

Smith ain’t doing any of that.

 

[swampcougar1]

Mensah and Toney will take votes away from each other. Good for the team but not good for winning Heisman

 

[RozayCane]

I like to believe that, but it’s Smith’s to lose.

Have you’ve seen OSU backup? Kid might not be able to get him the stats needed to stay at the top of the race

 

[ddann]

Mensah and Toney will take votes away from each other. Good for the team but not good for winning Heisman

Just like Dorsey and McGahee

 

[dstuart4]

Mensah and Toney will take votes away from each other. Good for the team but not good for winning Heisman

Yeah, look what happened in 2002. Dorsey and Willis canceled each other out. Can happen again, giving the statue to JS.

 

[Canesince85ND587]

Stats like he had yesterday when we play ND...give him the Heisman the race will be over.His only competion will be his QB.

Agree 200% but I hate to admit their def is better than pitts. They will do whatever they can to make someone else a playmaker. But if he does?

 

[Golsen82]

Smith will win it without Sayin. Everyone will say he would have ungodly numbers if Sayin was playing

 

[mynameisjeff]

If Smith maintains his current stats with a backup QB, gonna be tough.

Thankfully that's very unlikely. I think one of our guys lifts the trophy, especially if we beat ND.

 

[91Canes]

Early last year they threw quick screens to JS before they started opening up their playbook for sayin in the few games i watched

 

[Jonnyblaze]

Smith will win it without Sayin. Everyone will say he would have ungodly numbers if Sayin was playing

This. And even with Sayin out he’ll put up some kind of numbers.

I don’t see any way the Heisman voters don’t give it to Smith, who is going to finish his career as the all-time Big Ten leader in TD catches and yardage, and be Ohio State’s greatest receiver of all time.

 

[Colombie]

You guys are crazy.

Players don’t get benefits of the doubt with hypothetical numbers due to teammates being injured.

Especially if they lose a couple more games.

Maybe if they find a way to win out but even then it would be difficult.