Yes I do. We’d have two losses to CFP teams, one of which we did beat. Ohio State, Oregon, BYU all have worse losses than we would in this scenario. Our second loss also coming while all of those teams are at home, minus BYU/TT potentially.
Then comes the history and player factor. Odds are in the above scenario, we get the ten seed. They won’t schedule us vs ND or WF first round, BYU vs ND in South Bend instead of Provo would have so many more storylines than us playing in South Bend twice in a month. But you get the ‘26 Title rematch in IU. Plus Toney playing is a major win for us. These morons in the CFP committee can say whatever they want. But none of the teams you mentioned, minus Ohio State with Jeremiah Smith, have a player even remotely close to Toney’s watchability factor.
The only doomsday scenario is TT beating Utah. That leaves one spot between essentially us and BYU. BYU may have the edge in common opponents. But no Big 12 Title appearance, by far the worse loss. Does BYU sitting at home, at 10 warrant them staying there and us falling five spots? I don’t see it.