I’ll just leave this here

Why can they not just build a formula or a model that is fair and balanced (BCS style) and if they want to argue against that model they can do it and make it a public show and force them to explain why to the nation?
 
I'll play devil's advocate.

There are only 20 Power 4 teams with 3 or less losses.

3 of the 5 in the ACC are ranked
5 of the 5 in the Big 12 are ranked
6 of the 6 in the B1G are ranked
5 of the 5 in the SEC are ranked

That's only 21 teams. You have to rank 25. So you have to rank 6-4 teams, unless you think the G6 teams are better than the 4-loss Power teams.

So the only ones missing are Duke, who lost to a terrible GT team and their best win is Illinois, who is 6-4. And SMU, who just was down 42-0 at halftime of a game, at home. Who should be ranked in those 20-25 spots if not the SEC teams? Clemson, Pitt, and VT are 6-4 in the ACC.

Baylor, Arizona State, Oklahoma State are 6-4 in the Big 12.

5 teams in the Big 10 are 6-4.

I'm not saying I believe this, I'm just playing the other side of the argument, but if the ranking of the 4 loss SEC teams is completely egregious, your alternative is to.....rank a bunch of 6-4 Big 10 teams? Or Duke and SMU?
 
Last edited:
The unfortunate part is..everyone but the SEC gets the "ultimatum". As much as I hate ND..they were told that if they dont beat UM (especially without Mali Toney)..your out of the CFP... And I feel like we are being told the same...if we dont beat WF in the ACC title game...we are out. thats why they have us hovering around #7..to justify leaving us out. BUT if Bama or Texas lose to UGA in the SEC title game? We know they are in. They are setting the rankings up that way. Its ridiculous.
 
The unfortunate part is..everyone but the SEC gets the "ultimatum". As much as I hate ND..they were told that if they dont beat UM (especially without Mali Toney)..your out of the CFP... And I feel like we are being told the same...if we dont beat WF in the ACC title game...we are out. thats why they have us hovering around #7..to justify leaving us out. BUT if Bama or Texas lose to UGA in the SEC title game? We know they are in. They are setting the rankings up that way. Its ridiculous.
If we stay at 7, there’s a 0% chance we miss the playoffs if we lose to WF. WF is currently in the CFP. So they wouldn’t knock us from the spot.

Oregon, Ohio State, Iowa, UK, etc all need mass chaos to get in. Mass chaos either includes us losing inexplicably before the ACCCG, or us moving even higher.

They’d have to drop us five spots, behind teams who didn’t play. And much like last year, they’ve maintained not penalizing teams for playing in CCGs.
 
If we stay at 7, there’s a 0% chance we miss the playoffs if we lose to WF. WF is currently in the CFP. So they wouldn’t knock us from the spot.

Oregon, Ohio State, Iowa, UK, etc all need mass chaos to get in. Mass chaos either includes us losing inexplicably before the ACCCG, or us moving even higher.

They’d have to drop us five spots, behind teams who didn’t play. And much like last year, they’ve maintained not penalizing teams for playing in CCGs.

I'll never say anything is 0%, but you're obviously correct.

11-2 Miami with wins over a playoff team in Wake, and possibly a ranked Duke if they close the season with 2 wins, and losses to only 2 playoff teams in ND and Wake, is in the playoffs. We're not falling from 7 or higher to 12 for losing a conference championship game, that's absurdly silly. Provided we don't get blown off the field in Charlotte, then wins this and next Saturday lock us up a spot.
 
I'll never say anything is 0%, but you're obviously correct.

11-2 Miami with wins over a playoff team in Wake, and possibly a ranked Duke if they close the season with 2 wins, and losses to only 2 playoff teams in ND and Wake, is in the playoffs. We're not falling from 7 or higher to 12 for losing a conference championship game, that's absurdly silly. Provided we don't get blown off the field in Charlotte, then wins this and next Saturday lock us up a spot.
That is the key, IF we are 11-1 and lose close in Charlotte I think it is ok.

If Toney comes back, and WF wipes the field with us then we are in danger zone with getting left out EVEN though Alabama last season got obliterated in the SEC Title game, had like 2 yards rushing, and still got in.
 
The unfortunate part is..everyone but the SEC gets the "ultimatum". As much as I hate ND..they were told that if they dont beat UM (especially without Mali Toney)..your out of the CFP... And I feel like we are being told the same...if we dont beat WF in the ACC title game...we are out. thats why they have us hovering around #7..to justify leaving us out. BUT if Bama or Texas lose to UGA in the SEC title game? We know they are in. They are setting the rankings up that way. Its ridiculous.
We win our next 2 we're in. We're -5000.
 
That is the key, IF we are 11-1 and lose close in Charlotte I think it is ok.

If Toney comes back, and WF wipes the field with us then we are in danger zone with getting left out EVEN though Alabama last season got obliterated in the SEC Title game, had like 2 yards rushing, and still got in.

I just don't see a world where we drop 5 spots and almost nobody else plays. 1-2 is possible and there's precedence there. 5 is completely unprecedented by orders of magnitude.

If we lose 45-6, I guess it's possible. But if we lose 45-6 to Wake, do we even want to go to the playoffs anyway?

Either way, if we go win the next 2 games by 3 scores, which we'll be favored to do, we're going to the playoffs.
 
I'll never say anything is 0%, but you're obviously correct.

11-2 Miami with wins over a playoff team in Wake, and possibly a ranked Duke if they close the season with 2 wins, and losses to only 2 playoff teams in ND and Wake, is in the playoffs. We're not falling from 7 or higher to 12 for losing a conference championship game, that's absurdly silly. Provided we don't get blown off the field in Charlotte, then wins this and next Saturday lock us up a spot.
Screenshot_20261118_090807_DuckDuckGo.png


Let's assume (a big stretch) that these current teams all "win-out...ish" and the higher ranked conference team wins their respective championship game, except Miami loses to Wake Forest in ACC Champ tilt.

Suspend disbelief for a moment, I know.

The six automatic bids would go to Georgia (SEC), UCLA (B1G), Utah (Big 12), Wake Forest (ACC) and Boise State (top Group of 6) + ND being ranked within Top 12.

My guess at the 12, best seeds first:
1. Georgia
2. Utah
3. UCLA
4. Alabama (the committee has clearly shown an SEC title-game loss shouldn't drop them very far)
5. Texas
6. Notre Dame
7. Indiana
8. Wake Forest (jumping up for beating Miami)
9. Tennessee
10. ????????
11. ????????
12. Boise State

Vying for spots 10, 11 (remember Boise is guaranteed 12 slot at least and ND) are probably going to be Miami, BYU, Texas Tech, Oregon, and probably Ohio State. We know the above resumes aren't equal, but we aren't in the room are we?

Do we believe the Committee gives our Canes an unbiased and fair look for a ticket into one of those slots?

I've softened slightly my stance that a Miami loss in the ACCCG eliminates them from CFP, but my gut tells me the chance is not 0%.
 
Why can they not just build a formula or a model that is fair and balanced (BCS style) and if they want to argue against that model they can do it and make it a public show and force them to explain why to the nation?
Who is "They"? And what makes you think the SEC and ESPN is interested in fair and balanced?
 
View attachment 380536

Let's assume (a big stretch) that these current teams all "win-out...ish" and the higher ranked conference team wins their respective championship game, except Miami loses to Wake Forest in ACC Champ tilt.

Suspend disbelief for a moment, I know.

The six automatic bids would go to Georgia (SEC), UCLA (B1G), Utah (Big 12), Wake Forest (ACC) and Boise State (top Group of 6) + ND being ranked within Top 12.

My guess at the 12, best seeds first:
1. Georgia
2. Utah
3. UCLA
4. Alabama (the committee has clearly shown an SEC title-game loss shouldn't drop them very far)
5. Texas
6. Notre Dame
7. Indiana
8. Wake Forest (jumping up for beating Miami)
9. Tennessee
10. ????????
11. ????????
12. Boise State

Vying for spots 10, 11 (remember Boise is guaranteed 12 slot at least and ND) are probably going to be Miami, BYU, Texas Tech, Oregon, and probably Ohio State. We know the above resumes aren't equal, but we aren't in the room are we?

Do we believe the Committee gives our Canes an unbiased and fair look for a ticket into one of those slots?

I've softened slightly my stance that a Miami loss in the ACCCG eliminates them from CFP, but my gut tells me the chance is not 0%.

SEC is getting 4
B1G is getting 2
ACC is getting 1
Big12 is getting 2
ND is getting 1
G6 is getting 1

That's 11 spots, pretty much guaranteed. That 12th spot will come down to ACC Champ game loser, or a 3rd Big 12 team, or a 3rd B1G team. I'm very confident, if that ACC Champ game loser is an 11-2 Miami, we're in over a 3rd Big 12 team or 3rd B1G team.
 
I'll never say anything is 0%, but you're obviously correct.

11-2 Miami with wins over a playoff team in Wake, and possibly a ranked Duke if they close the season with 2 wins, and losses to only 2 playoff teams in ND and Wake, is in the playoffs. We're not falling from 7 or higher to 12 for losing a conference championship game, that's absurdly silly. Provided we don't get blown off the field in Charlotte, then wins this and next Saturday lock us up a spot.
View attachment 380536

Let's assume (a big stretch) that these current teams all "win-out...ish" and the higher ranked conference team wins their respective championship game, except Miami loses to Wake Forest in ACC Champ tilt.

Suspend disbelief for a moment, I know.

The six automatic bids would go to Georgia (SEC), UCLA (B1G), Utah (Big 12), Wake Forest (ACC) and Boise State (top Group of 6) + ND being ranked within Top 12.

My guess at the 12, best seeds first:
1. Georgia
2. Utah
3. UCLA
4. Alabama (the committee has clearly shown an SEC title-game loss shouldn't drop them very far)
5. Texas
6. Notre Dame
7. Indiana
8. Wake Forest (jumping up for beating Miami)
9. Tennessee
10. ????????
11. ????????
12. Boise State

Vying for spots 10, 11 (remember Boise is guaranteed 12 slot at least and ND) are probably going to be Miami, BYU, Texas Tech, Oregon, and probably Ohio State. We know the above resumes aren't equal, but we aren't in the room are we?

Do we believe the Committee gives our Canes an unbiased and fair look for a ticket into one of those slots?

I've softened slightly my stance that a Miami loss in the ACCCG eliminates them from CFP, but my gut tells me the chance is not 0%.
Yes I do. We’d have two losses to CFP teams, one of which we did beat. Ohio State, Oregon, BYU all have worse losses than we would in this scenario. Our second loss also coming while all of those teams are at home, minus BYU/TT potentially.

Then comes the history and player factor. Odds are in the above scenario, we get the ten seed. They won’t schedule us vs ND or WF first round, BYU vs ND in South Bend instead of Provo would have so many more storylines than us playing in South Bend twice in a month. But you get the ‘26 Title rematch in IU. Plus Toney playing is a major win for us. These morons in the CFP committee can say whatever they want. But none of the teams you mentioned, minus Ohio State with Jeremiah Smith, have a player even remotely close to Toney’s watchability factor.

The only doomsday scenario is TT beating Utah. That leaves one spot between essentially us and BYU. BYU may have the edge in common opponents. But no Big 12 Title appearance, by far the worse loss. Does BYU sitting at home, at 10 warrant them staying there and us falling five spots? I don’t see it.
 
There's only so many spots available....don't be disingenuous

How is that being disingenuous?

His literal, verbatim post was "You have to be .500 overall in the SEC to not be in the Top 25".

I said that's untrue, there are 3 teams in the SEC above .500 who are not ranked. These are simple facts.
 
Back
Top