4-0 in bowl games....beat several top 5 teams...beat FSU by year 4....managed to assemble NFLU....dealt w/ 30 lost schollys...went from 9-3 to 11-1 in year 4 to 5
0-2 in bowl games...have not beat a top 5 team....0-4 against FSU....managed to crap on So. Fla recruiting...dealing w/ 9 lost schollys (but not really, b/c 30% of his class either not made it or have transferred so they are recycling schollys)...went from 9-4 to 6-6(7)
Yep...I see a lot of similarities. Thanks OP for your blinded optimism.
The legend of Butch just keeps growing... I love Butch but some people have really forgotten those first 4 years. Let's revisit some of these "facts".
True but let's look at their first 4 years at UM:
1995 Bowl ban
1996 beat 7-5 Virginia team
1997 6-7 Not bowl eligible
1998 beat 7-5 NC State team
Golden:
2011 Bowl Ban
2012 Bowl Ban
2013 Lost to 12-1 Louisville team
2014 Will play 6-6 S. Carolina
Neither coach was all that impressive in their first 4 years.
beat several top 5 teams...
True but only 1 in his first 5 years. That was credited as the turning point for the program at the end of year 4. Golden blew his chance against FSU this year.
1995 0 Lost to #1 FSU, beat #22 Syracuse
1996 0 Lost to #3 FSU, beat #12 WVU and #16 Syracuse, lost #21 VT
1997 0 Lost to #4 FSU, lost to #24 Arizona State, #20 VT, #16 Syracuse
1998 1 Beat #3 UCLA, lost to #8 FSU and #21 Syracuse, beat #13 WVU
1999 0 Lost to #1 FSU, #3 Penn State, #2 VT, Beat #9 OSU, #17 GT
2000 2 #1 FSU, #2 VT
Golden:
2011 0 (Did not play any team in top 5) Played 3 ranked teams and won 2. #16 OSU W, #17 VT L, #22 GT W
2012 0 (Did not play any team in top 5) Played 3 ranked teams and lost all 3. #20 KSU W, #10 ND L, #10 FSU
2013 0 (played #3 FSU and lost) Beat #12 FL and lost to #18 Louisville
2014 0 Lost to #2 FSU. Lost to #24 Neb
In their first 4 years at Miami:
Golden is 0-2 against top 5 teams and 3-8 against ranked teams
Butch was 1-4 against top 5 teams and 5-9 against ranked teams
Not really... he beat them in year 5.
....
Absolutely
dealt w/ 30 lost schollys
...
Yes but don't understate the 3 year investigation under Golden. I understand that Butch lost 30 scholarships but let's not forget that he inherited a roster in 1995 with: 5 future first round picks: Ray Lewis, Yatil Green, Kenard Lang, Kenny Holmes, Duane Starks
Other NFL Players: Tremain Mack, Marcus Wimberley, Twan Russell, Tony Gaiter, Earl Little, James Burgess, KC Jones, Jammi German, Kerlin Blaise, Danyell Ferguson, Magic Benton, Nick Williams, Scott Covington, Derrick Ham, Ryan Clement, Carlos Jones, J Ina
With the exception of Ray Lewis he had all of these guys for at least 2 years. Al Golden got the class of 2008 and most them left after his first year along with the 2 best guys from 2009 (Miller, Vernon).
went from 9-3 to 11-1 in year 4 to 5
He went from 9-4 to 11-1 in year 6. Yes, he was 9-4 in year 5 and went from 9-3 to 9-4 from year 4-5.