I am not a Randy supporter, it is just eye opening to compare what we've done under F.A.G. to Randy. thats why he gets brought up
did randy recruit after 2008? - yeah 2009 was pretty decent, 2010 sucked for the most part but was very strong on OL AND overall, F.A.G. had a much better team in 2011 than Randy did in 2007. that is not even debatable.
yes there was a huge dropoff in 2012 due to recruiting holes and Randy def failed overall in that area from 2010-2011 BUT it isnt really clear at this point whether F.A.G. is doing any better at recruiting AND we are losing in embarrassing fashion with a historically bad defense.
Here were my questions:
Why are we comparing him to Al anyway? Compare a failure to a possible failure?
If the offense was explosive, wouldn't Al get the credit since he is the HC?
As to your post above, RS the recruiter.
2011 doesn't count for Al just like 2007 shouldn't count for RS (Even though RS was EMPLOYED at the school during that 2007 season), do we have to explain why 2011 doesn't count for Al?
Both Al and RS recruited well in their first real class, but for RS (even though we were cheating) things went down south badly and he left us with our d!ck in our hand for 2011. Remember some of these highly recruited kids never amounted to anything or were thrown out of school or never even enrolled (Arthur Brown, Prince Kent, Jermaine Johnson, Kevin Nelson, Travis Williams, Tavardis Glenn, Latwan Anderson and Storm Johnson).
RS's Product is finished as well. That beastly 2008 Class produced the following:
Brandon Harris (2nd Round), Sean Spence (3rd Round), Travis Benjamin (4th Round), Tommy Streeter (6th Round nothing under RS), Brandon Washington (6th Round) and Arthur Brown (2nd Round, not at Miami).
All those other 4 and 5 Star Guys in the 2008 Class: Aldarius Johnson, Davon Johnson (nothing under RS), Ben Jones, Jordan Futch, Vaughn Telemaque, Marcus Forston, Jacory Harris, Jeremey Lewis, CJ Holton and Cookie Buchanan....what happened? I guess these players weren't so good or weren't developed or some combination.
As for Al, although we missed on some players in 2013/2014. His 2013 and 2014 classes were pretty darn good and show a lot of promise. Let's not forget that in 2012 & 2013 we had to deal with the unknown of the CLOUD.
I strongly disagree that Al isn't doing better at recruiting.
I guess you missed it before
Here is RS's tenure in the ACC
07: 2-6
08: 4-4
09: 5-3 (3 Year Total 11-13 or 46%)
10: 5-3
Total: 16-16 (.50%)
Here is Al's Tenure in the ACC
11: 3-5
12: 5-3
13: 5-3
Total: 13-11 (.54%)
In the battle of the biggest loser, RS won. RS had a losing record in the ACC after 3 years.
Beating RS isn't hard to do, but Al seems to be getting close to unemployment if he doesn't fix things in the W/L column soon.