ESPN Miami QB Mt Rushmore

[Go Canes!!]

Kelly, Kosar, Testaverde and Dorsey got my votes. Tough leaving Walsh off.

 

[AtlAtty]

Kelly, Kosar, Testaverde and Dorsey got my votes. Tough leaving Walsh off.

I loved Dorsey but I can't put him in over Walsh. Frankly, I thought Craig Erickson was better than Dorsey. Erickson to me is the criminally undervalued UM quarterback.

 

[Heart of The Playmaker]

Kelly, Kosar, Testaverde and Dorsey got my votes. Tough leaving Walsh off.

Same...we have a Heisman winner that isn't even on there...we are blessed

 

[dk72]

Kelly, Kosar, Testaverde and Dorsey got my votes. Tough leaving Walsh off.

I would agree with your 4, with honorable mention for Walsh, Toretta, and Erickson.

 

[ddann]

I loved Dorsey but I can't put him in over Walsh. Frankly, I thought Craig Erickson was better than Dorsey. Erickson to me is the criminally undervalued UM quarterback.

If Erickson could’ve willed the team to victory over BYU and/or ND in ‘90, then he would be impossible to overlook.

 

[AtlAtty]

If Erickson could’ve willed the team to victory over BYU and/or ND in ‘90, then he would be impossible to overlook.

He did win the NC in '89.
My freshman year at UM FYI so maybe I am forever biased.

 

[Golsen82]

My miami QB Mt Rushmore

Jarren Williams, Kyle Wright, Malik Rosier,
Nkosi Perry

 

[Golsen82]

I loved Dorsey but I can't put him in over Walsh. Frankly, I thought Craig Erickson was better than Dorsey. Erickson to me is the criminally undervalued UM quarterback.

Erickson severely underrated

 

[AtlAtty]

My miami QB Mt Rushmore

Jarren Williams, Kyle Wright, Malik Rosier,
Nkosi Perry

No Kirby Freeman and his ONE pass completion against NC State?

 

[caneULM]

My miami QB Mt Rushmore

Jarren Williams, Kyle Wright, Malik Rosier,
Nkosi Perry

At least they all beat FSU.

 

[CANEMC]

 

[Gables Canes]

****, no love for Preston Dewey?

 

[RiDLer80]

So basically we haven't had a QB worth a **** in 20 years? Cool.

 

[dk72]

****, no love for Preston Dewey?

Gray Crow for the win!

 

[We'retheBoss]

Buck Ortega 4 times

 

[Boarcane]

However amazing Kelly was, he shouldn’t be on the list. He didn’t win a Heisman, national title or impact the college game as much as four or five others on that list. His professional resume shouldn’t carry any weight here. Kosar, Vinny, Dorsey and whatever fifth you’d like. There’s three to choose from imho. Kelly would be my number one if this was a draft

 

[P-Tizzle]

Erickson, Kosar, Walsh, and Dorsey

Give me titles and NFL experience.

 

[Silentobserver]

My miami QB Mt Rushmore

Jarren Williams, Kyle Wright, Malik Rosier,
Nkosi Perry

Kirby Freeman?

How could you have left him off?

 

[ItsAUThing.com]

I loved Dorsey but I can't put him in over Walsh. Frankly, I thought Craig Erickson was better than Dorsey. Erickson to me is the criminally undervalued UM quarterback.

All those guys were great, but Testaverde / Walsh / Erickson were all of the same era and ilk; 1985 through 1990, where two titles were won.

Testaverde gets the nod from that era, but impossible to leave 38-2 Ken Dorsey off—who should've been 39-1, won the 2001 or 2002 Heisman Trophy and been a two-time national champion, if not for that bogus flag. Talk about a legacy stolen.

KELLY, KOSAR, TESTAVERDE and DORSEY.

****, based on Vinny's choke in the Fiesta, I'd punt him for Steve Walsh before I leave Ken Dorsey off this list.

 

[HarpDawg]

kosar, testaverde, kelly, erickson/walsh