- Joined
- Dec 22, 2011
- Messages
- 43,764
Because Reed doesn't want to start from the ground up. You could look to Deion never being a position coach, but Deion was a HS HC for 3 years (to coach his son's team, but still, didn't start off at the college/position level).
Here's the thing.
Ed and Deion were great players, no doubt. And at that level of achievement, I can understand them wanting to start at a high level of coaching instead of starting at the bottom, though I don't agree with their views.
Having said that, even if we could agree with their viewpoint...
A) How does being a great player train a guy to START at a coaching level that requires more than just teaching the position they were great at, and
B) When has this approach ever worked in the history of college or NFL coaching?
That's all. Now, Deion got incredibly lucky. He transformed what some would see as a "volunteer job" (coaching one's sons in a sport) into what seemed like a dead-end HBCU job (but which benefitted greatly from his celebrity as much as his coaching) into a P5 head coaching job at a thirsty school desparate for traction.
I respect Ed Reed. I just think that if he wants to coach, he is better off starting out as a position coach, MAYBE a Co-DC.