Brown vs Fletcher/Pringle is a different conversation than Brown vs Lyle.He was "huge" in critical times, because he's the one they put on the field. If they put Fletcher in those moments, I think it'd have pretty much done the same honestly. So the reality should maybe have been more having Fletcher for those scenarios and having had Pringle worked in more earlier in the game too... Plus If they got more Pringle involved I think he can be a real receiving threat. I think people have been overly critical on his pass blocking... But sure if you say in big moments you wouldn't have wanted to rely on him thats fine, but throught the game? especially 1st halves....
I think Lyle could certainly be a receiving option and likely a fine blocker. He's built quite well. And again those late moments where like we had Brown in because we were in clear pass situations... Wouldn't say Lyles run efficiency really would be a big negative.
But again my main point is I don't think Brown has a big ceiling, and we have 1 guy just plainly better in Fletcher, and 2 more who could probably deliver at least 90% of what he does in Lofton and Mallory already.... Lyle IF he can get to the ceiling or something close provides something much different. Either way I'd still think Pringle is RB2. This is a RB3 competition. Basically I don't see any way Brown should be more than RB3, wherease IF Lyle truly played to his potential I wouldn't be surprised to see him overtake for RB2.... which is Why I'd prefer to take the shot on him still.
I agree Fletcher/Pringle are more dynamic runners than Brown and should be higher on the depth chart. Brown is a very dependable but no flash RB. I agree there isn't much more ceiling to his game.
But running, receiving, blocking - Brown is better than Lyle. Lyle has more speed - but that's it. I'd take Brown over Lyle in any situation in any quarter.
Brown had 6 carries on the final drive vs ND. He had 5 runs on the final drive vs Ohio St. I think he was on the field ahead of Fletcher for receiving purposes, but he was also leaned on heavily as a runner in nut crunch time. He was also on the field to close all other our close games - Indiana, FSU, SMU. So when the coaches needed a closer - Brown was their guy a large majority of the time.
Louisville was the one game he didn't close. Lyle closed, and he fumbled his last carry
Lyle is an ok RB. But the idea of Lyle's ceiling/what he can be has always been & will continue to be greater than the reality of what he's capable of doing.
Last edited: