Duke Fumble on 4th and 1??

This was my thing... we were pretty adamant it was a fumble, Duke TE looked like he lost his puppy, and the Duke sideline was rushing a new play in so all the signs were there like you said to take a look. Perhaps on the all 22 it is painfully obvious and that back ref made a no brainer of a call.

That is ultimately what I told myself, he must have been clearly down then the ball came out but when I saw the above angle and the way he moves the ball away from his body and is so nonchalant, definitely seems like the ball could be "moving" slightly before he was down.

And like others have said, the refs were so quick to check OBVIOUS plays or a simple 1/2 yard spot here and there, not on like a crucial play, just a normal ball spot, why not at least show a replay of this? ABC just skipped right over.

Does @Ironmanfootball have the all 22 for this one?
I have the game if you can give me the time/quarter I can pull it up
 
The FSU Hail Mary call went our way, so I wasn’t too outraged lol
The poo call could've went either way. Honestly it probably should've been a td. The question becomes how you establish simultaneous possession. Initially it was. But in establishing possession you can clearly see bryce takes the ball from him. But it goes back and forth twice where each lost possession. Ultimately ending with Bryce.
 
The poo call could've went either way. Honestly it probably should've been a td. The question becomes how you establish simultaneous possession. Initially it was. But in establishing possession you can clearly see bryce takes the ball from him. But it goes back and forth twice where each lost possession. Ultimately ending with Bryce.
Based on how they explain what a "catch" is now after the Lofton/ND issue, I was more convinced they got the call right. If we are operating under this, as soon as a foot touches and he has possession it is a catch, I agree, its a TD, same ish happened years ago when we played UF when Spence was on the team. IDK why I remember this but we were hanging with them close, then 3rd quarter, one of their WR makes a crucial 3rd down catch, he fell and his elbow hit inbounds and as soon as his body hit the ball pops out, they ruled it a catch cuz once his elbow hit, play was over so ground doesnt matter, now apparently the rule changed where you have to maintain control. Deuce def did not have control once they came down. If Lofton's catch wasnt a TD, no way that could be a TD.
 
Based on how they explain what a "catch" is now after the Lofton/ND issue, I was more convinced they got the call right. If we are operating under this, as soon as a foot touches and he has possession it is a catch, I agree, its a TD, same ish happened years ago when we played UF when Spence was on the team. IDK why I remember this but we were hanging with them close, then 3rd quarter, one of their WR makes a crucial 3rd down catch, he fell and his elbow hit inbounds and as soon as his body hit the ball pops out, they ruled it a catch cuz once his elbow hit, play was over so ground doesnt matter, now apparently the rule changed where you have to maintain control. Deuce def did not have control once they came down. If Lofton's catch wasnt a TD, no way that could be a TD.
My mind also went straight to comparing those 2 plays.
 
I mean they reviewed a run by Fletcher for a first down that he clearly had by 1yd and didn't review for a potential fumble on a 4th play! They don't even hide the incompetence or that they are gambling on the game. Whenever you see that white hat, you know that its going to be horribly officiated.
 
I mean they reviewed a run by Fletcher for a first down that he clearly had by 1yd and didn't review for a potential fumble on a 4th play! They don't even hide the incompetence or that they are gambling on the game. Whenever you see that white hat, you know that its going to be horribly officiated.
They did it to slow us down. No way the replay booth needed to call down on that. Was clear as day it was a first down but we were trying to go with tempo and Duke was trying to sub. I am 1000% convinced they were doing anything they could to keep it close.
 
sidenote, what on earth is Thornton doing on this 4th down play? Dude is lined up 20yds off the ball on a 4th and 1 with not a single receiver on the field. Guy is selling popcorn in the mezzanine section. Good heavens man. I understand what his job is there but my lord, he might as well not even been of the field. Than JJ, kids eyes are never where they should be.
 
What if I told you that Magellanes was the referee for the 2015 Duke Corn Elder game?


My theory is they gave him his job back on the condition that he take his pre-game orders from the head office.
That explains a lot. He must hold a grudge for making national news.
 
Back
Top