Duke Fumble on 4th and 1??

Cookie917

Recruit
Joined
Jun 27, 2017
Messages
4,135
Does anyone have another angle of that 4th and 1 play where Duke converted and Marcelin knocked it out?? You can see when the TE goes to shake Thornton that he puts the ball super far away from his body, Marcelin hits him immediately and looks to get the ball immediately. The TE did not jump up pointing to the ground, he sure looked like he thought he lost the ball but then we do not get a single replay and the refs allow them to hurry up and snap it so Duke was also concerned. It was 4th and 1 from the 40 with 11 min in the second. We stop them there we have great field position.

Below is the only other link I could find and of course it cuts off like a second too early.

 
I watch 20 football games a week. About 99.99% of the time, when there's a very close call and one team rushes to the line to try to snap the ball, knowing the call is close, the refs blow the play dead and look. Well, I guess we're in that 0.01%, shockingly.

I really want to see the All-22 of this play, or another angle, because if it's not COMPLETELY obvious he was down on the very first look, then the refs and the replay center were simply flat on their asses.

He might've been down, but Marcelin had that ball pretty **** quick after impact on the ground.
 
I watch 20 football games a week. About 99.99% of the time, when there's a very close call and one team rushes to the line to try to snap the ball, knowing the call is close, the refs blow the play dead and look. Well, I guess we're in that 0.01%, shockingly.

I really want to see the All-22 of this play, or another angle, because if it's not COMPLETELY obvious he was down on the very first look, then the refs and the replay center were simply flat on their asses.

He might've been down, but Marcelin had that ball pretty **** quick after impact on the ground.
This was my thing... we were pretty adamant it was a fumble, Duke TE looked like he lost his puppy, and the Duke sideline was rushing a new play in so all the signs were there like you said to take a look. Perhaps on the all 22 it is painfully obvious and that back ref made a no brainer of a call.

That is ultimately what I told myself, he must have been clearly down then the ball came out but when I saw the above angle and the way he moves the ball away from his body and is so nonchalant, definitely seems like the ball could be "moving" slightly before he was down.

And like others have said, the refs were so quick to check OBVIOUS plays or a simple 1/2 yard spot here and there, not on like a crucial play, just a normal ball spot, why not at least show a replay of this? ABC just skipped right over.

Does @Ironmanfootball have the all 22 for this one?
 
I watch 20 football games a week. About 99.99% of the time, when there's a very close call and one team rushes to the line to try to snap the ball, knowing the call is close, the refs blow the play dead and look. Well, I guess we're in that 0.01%, shockingly.

I really want to see the All-22 of this play, or another angle, because if it's not COMPLETELY obvious he was down on the very first look, then the refs and the replay center were simply flat on their asses.

He might've been down, but Marcelin had that ball pretty **** quick after impact on the ground.
Exactly. As others have alluded, all the tells showed that it was atleast a close play worth looking at.

Mario needs to wake up a little bit in these situations. Burn a timeout if you have to.
 
I watch 20 football games a week. About 99.99% of the time, when there's a very close call and one team rushes to the line to try to snap the ball, knowing the call is close, the refs blow the play dead and look. Well, I guess we're in that 0.01%, shockingly.

I really want to see the All-22 of this play, or another angle, because if it's not COMPLETELY obvious he was down on the very first look, then the refs and the replay center were simply flat on their asses.

He might've been down, but Marcelin had that ball pretty **** quick after impact on the ground.

I personally thought sitting in section 235 row 10 going into that end zone, it looked like a fumble to me when it happened.
 
I have a weird related question. I was watching a professional game. Where the quarterback was trying to spike the ball
The defender slid under the hands of the center and was within 1 or 2 inches of catching the spike on the way to the ground
I am wondering whether or not it would have been an interception.
 
I have a weird related question. I was watching a professional game. Where the quarterback was trying to spike the ball
The defender slid under the hands of the center and was within 1 or 2 inches of catching the spike on the way to the ground
I am wondering whether or not it would have been an interception.
Yes it would have been an interception.
 
Does anyone have another angle of that 4th and 1 play where Duke converted and Marcelin knocked it out?? You can see when the TE goes to shake Thornton that he puts the ball super far away from his body, Marcelin hits him immediately and looks to get the ball immediately. The TE did not jump up pointing to the ground, he sure looked like he thought he lost the ball but then we do not get a single replay and the refs allow them to hurry up and snap it so Duke was also concerned. It was 4th and 1 from the 40 with 11 min in the second. We stop them there we have great field position.

Below is the only other link I could find and of course it cuts off like a second too early.


Perfect example of Dunnigan not doing his job.
 
The shovel pass was more egregious. The replay conversation is literally them saying “we have nothing showing it isn’t a lateral, the receiver is at the 26, he throws at the 26” and about to uphold the call of a fumble. Then someone who hasn’t spoken comes on and goes “yeah the receiver is beyond the 26” and they move immediately to “anyone disagree?” MFer WAHT
 
They pretty much review every close turnover at this point. Why not this one? However, they did review the play prior over a half yard difference on the spot. Make it make sense. Oh right, Tobacco Road mafia sent in their man. Guess who will be doing the ACC Championship game.
Zagacki called out the Head ref in the pre game show. Said he is notorious in his bias and has a long history of calling penalties against the Canes. Well, there you have it. Joe was spot on.
 
The shovel pass was more egregious. The replay conversation is literally them saying “we have nothing showing it isn’t a lateral, the receiver is at the 26, he throws at the 26” and about to uphold the call of a fumble. Then someone who hasn’t spoken comes on and goes “yeah the receiver is beyond the 26” and they move immediately to “anyone disagree?” MFer WAHT
I was raging man. I hate using refs as an excuse but Saturday was egregious on multiple fronts.
 
The shovel pass was more egregious. The replay conversation is literally them saying “we have nothing showing it isn’t a lateral, the receiver is at the 26, he throws at the 26” and about to uphold the call of a fumble. Then someone who hasn’t spoken comes on and goes “yeah the receiver is behind the 26” and they move immediately to “anyone disagree?” MFer WAHT
100%

Dude who didn't speak the entire review chimes in and they all happen to agree with him
 
Back
Top