Duke Fumble on 4th and 1??

I watch 20 football games a week. About 99.99% of the time, when there's a very close call and one team rushes to the line to try to snap the ball, knowing the call is close, the refs blow the play dead and look. Well, I guess we're in that 0.01%, shockingly.

I really want to see the All-22 of this play, or another angle, because if it's not COMPLETELY obvious he was down on the very first look, then the refs and the replay center were simply flat on their asses.

He might've been down, but Marcelin had that ball pretty **** quick after impact on the ground.
I’m really hoping the all 22 cam is from that end zone. Will post as soon as I have it.
 
The shovel pass was more egregious. The replay conversation is literally them saying “we have nothing showing it isn’t a lateral, the receiver is at the 26, he throws at the 26” and about to uphold the call of a fumble. Then someone who hasn’t spoken comes on and goes “yeah the receiver is beyond the 26” and they move immediately to “anyone disagree?” MFer WAHT
lolI noticed this as well but kind stfu about it because I thought the same thing worked in our favor on the Fail Mary from FSU on the Bryce INT. One guy was like yup see here, Defender has his hands on the ball and as they are showing the replay I am going uhhh I dont see it there, then everyone starts chiming in agreeing it was Defense ball so I was cool with it but yeah these discussions are super weird now that we get to hear them. Its like if one guy is just overly assertive everyone else agrees. I think that dude even said something like it hit him in the face and his head is further than where his feet are or something crazy like that.
 
If its a Jerry Magallanes crew we are always going to be in for a long night. Facts. This game was trending like the SMU game last year but we just had too much for the officials to overcome.

The more troubling one was that video review of the fumble like Indy mentioned. All voices in agreement there is not enough info to overturn the call then some shadowy voice that hasn't previously said anything chimes in with "yeah the receiver is beyond the twenty six" and nobody even debates it. They just all fall in line with "anyone in disagreement" and immediately change the call. That was CRAZY

Im more along the lines of officials are just bad at what they do or maybe have some subconscious bias but this game definitely looked like more than that.
 
Do you want to know what is even more egregious?


On the CIS podcast today, Ahmmon said it's unreasonable to believe a corner should make a tackle on the QB when he's blitzing. WTF are we doing.
 
The shovel pass was more egregious. The replay conversation is literally them saying “we have nothing showing it isn’t a lateral, the receiver is at the 26, he throws at the 26” and about to uphold the call of a fumble. Then someone who hasn’t spoken comes on and goes “yeah the receiver is beyond the 26” and they move immediately to “anyone disagree?” MFer WAHT
ACC exposed themselves on that replay. Up to this point, I was always impressed by the thorough review and how they communicated it to everyone listening. As you mentioned, the call was just about to be sent in. Suddenly a bat signal was made and you have some dude completely overrule everything that was said for about 2 minutes? That was some shady **** right there. And let's be honest maybe it wasn't a fumble. At best it was a sideways throw, which I believe is not a lateral. But in no world was the receiver actually in front of the QB as this ghost man suddenly comes out of nowhere and states.
 
The shovel pass was more egregious. The replay conversation is literally them saying “we have nothing showing it isn’t a lateral, the receiver is at the 26, he throws at the 26” and about to uphold the call of a fumble. Then someone who hasn’t spoken comes on and goes “yeah the receiver is beyond the 26” and they move immediately to “anyone disagree?” MFer WAHT
Every week the announcers say how great it is they have this level of transparency with the command center, but all it shows me is how dumb the ACC refs and command center are lol
 
The shovel pass was more egregious. The replay conversation is literally them saying “we have nothing showing it isn’t a lateral, the receiver is at the 26, he throws at the 26” and about to uphold the call of a fumble. Then someone who hasn’t spoken comes on and goes “yeah the receiver is beyond the 26” and they move immediately to “anyone disagree?” MFer WAHT
Yea listening to some of these booth discussions makes the refs look terrible. I wonder how some of these people got that job. Half the time they are not discussing the main point at hand, and way too many times I’ve heard the opinion of one person instantly impact how others think. This review was a good example of both.
 
Its crazy they looked at the spot to give Duke half a yard but crickets on a potential turnover. Duke OL holding all game and not one call. Lofton tackled in the endzone, no call but they get O'Connor late in the game on a BS PI.
I started paying attention to how they were spotting the ball as well. It was literally a half yard positive spot for Duke and a half yard negative spot for us on countless plays.
 
It was like the refs had money that we wouldn't cover.
Anyone who has done much sports betting will confirm that Vegas controls alot more outcomes than fans want to admit. This game? Who knows. Just too much $ involved. It might not be WWF fake.. but it's something.
 
ACC exposed themselves on that replay. Up to this point, I was always impressed by the thorough review and how they communicated it to everyone listening. As you mentioned, the call was just about to be sent in. Suddenly a bat signal was made and you have some dude completely overrule everything that was said for about 2 minutes? That was some shady **** right there. And let's be honest maybe it wasn't a fumble. At best it was a sideways throw, which I believe is not a lateral. But in no world was the receiver actually in front of the QB as this ghost man suddenly comes out of nowhere and states.
lol this **** happens every week. Go back and watch the discussion last year about the SMU “catch” on the sideline. Or the fumble in the Clemson/Louisville game that went out right around the pylon.
 
lol this **** happens every week. Go back and watch the discussion last year about the SMU “catch” on the sideline. Or the fumble in the Clemson/Louisville game that went out right around the pylon.
better yet look at the JJ "catch" in the taint game over the weekend

 
Back
Top